BOTTLEPRO
  • Home
  • Learn
    • Best Bottle Calculator
    • Comparisons and Insulation Tests
    • Health and Hydration
    • Sip or Skip (Individual Bottles) >
      • Bottles >
        • Camelbak
        • EcoVessel
        • Fjbottle
        • Healthy Human
        • Hydro Flask >
          • Hydro Flask Standard
          • Hydro Flask Trail
          • Hydro Flask Wide
        • Iron Flask
        • Klean Kanteen TKWide
        • Nalgene
        • Owala FreeSip
        • Ozark Trail
        • RevoMax
        • S'well Original
        • Takeya
        • ThermoFlask
        • YETI Rambler
      • Tumblers >
        • Brumate Era
        • Hydro Flask
        • Owala FreeSip Sway
        • Simple Modern
        • Stanley >
          • Stanley Quencher
          • Stanley IceFlow
          • Stanley ProTour
      • Specialty Bottles (Filters, Infusing) >
        • Brita (Filter)
        • Cirkul (Infusing)
        • GRAYL (Filter)
        • LARQ (UV)
        • Stanley Thermos (Insulation)
        • Steepware (Infusing)
        • Vesmoon (Infusing)
        • Vitaloop (Filter)
        • Zulu Ace (Removable Base)
  • Shop
    • Cup Holder Adapter
    • Infusers >
      • FlavorFuze Pod
      • FlavorFuze Straw
      • FlavorFuze Steel
    • Splash Guard
  • Demos
  • Hydration Blog
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Find a Store

What is the Best Travel Mug? (Our Biggest Comparison Yet!)

9/29/2025

0 Comments

 
What is the Best Travel Mug?
What is the Best Travel Mug?

What is the Best Travel Mug for Coffee and Tea?

If you're wondering what is the best travel mug, you're not alone.  There are thousands of travel mugs, tumblers, and coffee bottles on the market today, so it can be a big overwhelming.  The good news is that I've collected, tested, and overanalyzed many of the most of the popular brands over the years for this business, and today I'll show you my full collection to help you find the best travel mug for your preferences and lifestyle.

Depending on where you look, this type of bottle may also be called "travel tumblers," "travel bottles," or "coffee bottles."  Because this post focuses on mugs and tumblers that are easier for traveling, ones with side-mounted handles are not included because they are not as compatible with many cupholders.  But we'll have a separate post focusing on those soon!

What's Next?

  • ​Video review
  • Good accessories to have regardless of which bottle you go with
  • Part One: Giving my recommendations for the best (and worst) bottles travel mugs for different uses, like driving, value, and overall.
  • Part Two: Deeper review of each travel mug, including the main pros and cons.

Video Review: What is the Best Travel Mug?

This video goes into even more detail and analysis about each bottle by ranking them all according to 12 different criteria, so check this out for an even deeper dive!

Good Accessories for Most Travel Mugs

Whether you go with Fellow, Stanley, YETI, or Zojirushi, these are two fo our most popular recommended accessories that help make cleaning any big reusable bottle much easier.
Brush Kit
Brush Kit
Bottle Brush Kit
​There are a lot of brush kits on Amazon at this point, so feel free to shop around.  This is the one I have, and it has a range of brush sizes that work with any bottle.

It's worth noting that some bottles with wider openings like YETI's Rambler tumblers may be wide enough for your hand to fit, so you may not actually need a brush kit like this (see the cleaning section below for more details).
See Brush Kit
Cleaning Tablets
Cleaning Tablets
Cleaning Tablets
I've tested these, and they work really well when cleaning out coffee and tea stains.  I also recommend using them roughly once per week during your deep cleaning routine.

Bottle Bright tablets are the big name, and it's hard to go wrong with them.  Alternatively, you could choose denture or retainer tablets to save some money.  They all work pretty similarly.

See Cleaning Tablets

Part One: Recommended by Use

Different travel mugs are better for different situations, so here let's take a look at various uses to see which bottle is the best option.

Scroll down to Part Two to read more about any particular brand or bottle.
Best Travel Mug for Everyday, All-Around Use
These are the two travel mugs I've recently found myself going back to most regularly when I'm not deliberately testing a new one.  They each have a great combination of features that make them outstanding options for everyday use.
Owala SmoothSip's Slider Lid
Owala SmoothSip's Slider Lid
Owala SmoothSip
  • Ergonomic sip opening (feels weirdly better)
  • Tapered for cupholders
  • Easy to clean all surfaces​
See Owala
Zojirushi's Spring-Loaded Lid
Zojirushi's Spring-Loaded Lid
Zojirushi
  • Ridiculously good insulation
  • Cover keeps the drinking surface clean
  • Easy to clean all surfaces
See Zojirushi
YETI Magslider's Slider
YETI Magslider's Slider
YETI Magslider
  • Easiest travel mug to clean
  • Very durable
  • Popular gift, particularly for men
See YETI
Fellow Carter Move's Traditional Lid
Fellow Carter Move's Traditional Lid
Fellow Carter Move
  • Comfy curved rim design
  • Avoids plastic contact with your mouth and drink
  • Great insulation
See Fellow
Worst Travel Mug for Everyday Use: Frank Green (more on this further down)
Best Travel Mug for Value
Weto Weto Tumbler
Weto Weto Tumbler
Weto Weto
  • Capable alternative to more expensive tumblers like YETI's Magslider
  • Tapered for cupholders
  • Harder to clean around the slider​
See Weto Weto
Contigo Byron
Contigo Byron
Contigo Byron
  • Inexpensive and from a well-known brand
  • Steel base to prevent scratches, and silicone grip around the middle.
  • Unable to fully disassemble the lid for cleaning
See Contigo
Best Travel Mug for Driving, Commutes, and Road Trips
Simple Modern Voyager's Push Button
Simple Modern Voyager's Push Button
Simple Modern Voyager
  • One big button that's easy to push to open and close
  • Sip from any side
  • Tapered for cupholders
See Simple Modern
YETI Magslider
YETI Magslider
YETI Magslider
  • Easiest slider-style lid to open/close
  • Tapered for cupholders
  • Notably, it's leak-resistant but not fully leak-free
See Contigo
Honorable Mention: Stanley Aerolight Transit (narrow design, lid cover pushes all the way back to stay out of your view), Owala SmoothSip (tapered for cupholders, one-handed open/close)
Worst Travel Mugs for Driving: Fellow Carter Move (2-handed open/close, wider base than most, lid isn't tethered, wide mouth with the fastest flow even with the splash guard inserted), YETI Hotshot (very bulky, 2-handed open/close)
Best Travel Mugs with Ceramic Lined Interiors
Fellow's Ceramic Coating
Fellow's Ceramic Coating
Fellow Carter Move
  • Has an off-white colored ceramic coating, which makes it easy to see your drink level​
See Fellow
Coating
Simple Modern's Ceramic Coating
Simple Modern Voyager
  • ​Has a clear ceramic coating, so it looks like the same color as the mug​
See Simple modern
Best Travel Mug for Insulation
Zojirushi has the Best Insulation
Zojirushi has the Best Insulation
Zojirushi
  • Top-ranked insulation for both hot and cold tests​
  • Insulation is helped by the narrower mouth opening and seal design
  • Narrower neck makes it harder to clean or add ice
See Zojirushi
Fellow has Great Insulation
Fellow has Great Insulation
Fellow Carter Move
  • 2nd-ranked insulation
  • The insulated standard lid (screw on and off to sip) and seal design are great for insulation​
See Fellow
Honorable Mentions: Stanley Aerolight Transit and YETI Hotshot
Worst Travel Mugs for Insulation: With vacuum insulated bottles, most heat transfers through the lid.  That's why a general rule-of-thumb is that bottles with wider rims have worse insulation.  This includes traditional tumblers like YETI's Magslider, Healthy Human's Cruiser, Owala's SmoothSip, Simple Modern's Voyager, and Weto Weto's tumbler.
Best Travel Mug for Home or Office
Zojirushi's Narrow Design
Zojirushi's Narrow Design
Zojirushi
  • Narrow design takes up less space on a desk
  • Great insulation
  • Easy to clean
See Zojirushi
YETI Magslider's Durable Base
YETI Magslider's Durable Base
YETI Magslider
  • Very durable
  • Easiest travel mug to clean
  • Great slider (but notably not 100% leakproof)​
See YETI
Honorable Mention: Hydro Flask Flex Sip (has a handle that you can grab with one finger when holding other things, like if you're carrying several things and your bottle to a meeting), Stanley Aerolight Transit (good combination of small diameter to take up less space, lightweight, and good insulation)
Worst Travel Mugs for Home or Office: YETI Hotshot (very large and bulky with no handle)
Best Travel Mug for Easy Cleaning
YETI Magslider's Removable Slider
YETI Magslider's Removable Slider
YETI Magslider
  • Magnetic slider easily pops off for cleaning
  • Wide rim means you likely don't need a bottle brush
  • No hidden or hard-to-reach seals or areas
See YETI
Owala SmoothSip's Removable Slider
Owala SmoothSip's Removable Slider
Owala SmoothSip
  • No hard-to-reach or hidden spots, other than needing a straw cleaner for the spout opening
  • Wide rim, so no big brush needed
  • External threads makes the rim seal easy to clean
  • Handwash recommended, but technically dishwasher safe
See Owala
YETI Hotshot / Commuter's 2-Piece Lid
YETI Hotshot / Commuter's 2-Piece Lid
YETI Hotshot / Commuter
  • Simple 2-piece lid is easy to clean
  • You'll likely just need one brush (a big one for the bottle)
  • If you get the newer Commuter, you may not need a bottle brush because the bottle has a wider opening
See YETI
Healthy Human's Simple Lid
Healthy Human's Simple Lid
Healthy Human Cruiser
  • About as simple as you can get with no moving parts, so it's easy to clean
  • No hard-to-reach or hidden spots, other than needing a straw cleaner for the stainless steel straw
  • Wide rim, so no big brush needed
See Healthy Human
Honorable Mention: Zojirushi (for a complex lid it's well-designed and surprisingly easy to clean, but you'll want several brush sizes from a kit like this one)
Worst Travel Mugs for Easy Cleaning: Frank Green (ridiculously complex to disassemble the lid) and Simple Modern Voyager (unable to disassemble the lid)
Best Travel Mug for Clumsy People (Most Durable)
Magnetic Slider Avoids Plastic Connections that can Break
Magnetic Slider Avoids Plastic Connections that can Break
YETI Magslider
  • YETIs are known for being overbuilt and durable
  • Stainless steel bottom prevents scratches
  • Magnetic slider avoids plastic connections that can break
See YETI
Fellow's Rounded Edges Help Prevent Dents
Fellow's Rounded Edges Help Prevent Dents
Fellow Carter Move
  • Simple design avoids small plastic parts, springs, and connections
  • Rounded edges can scratch, but they avoided dents better compared to other options
See Fellow
Least Durable Travel Mugs: Frank Green (many small plastic parts), Zojirushi (scratches easily), Weto Weto (slider is hard to clean around without damaging the plastic connection)
The Most Popular Travel Mugs and Best to Give as a Gift
Owala...So Hot Right Now
Owala...So Hot Right Now
Owala SmoothSip
  • Trendy, particularly with younger consumers
  • Fun color options are appealing to many
See Owala
YETI's Magslider is Very Popular
YETI's Magslider is Very Popular
YETI Magslider
  • Popular gift, particularly for men
  • Classic, simple design that's easy for most people to get used to quickly
See YETI
Fellow's Sleek Minimalist Design
Fellow's Sleek Minimalist Design
Fellow Carter Move
  • Sleek design and solid construction make it a great gift for both men and women
See Fellow
Zojirushi's Well-Designed Lid
Zojirushi's Well-Designed Lid
Zojirushi
  • The well-designed lid and ridiculously good insulation has earned a devoted following
See Zojirushi
Best Travel Mug for Safety and Limiting Plastic Contact
Fellow's Stainless Steel under the Lid
Fellow's Stainless Steel under the Lid
Fellow Carter Move
  • Avoids plastic contact with your mouth or drink
  • Stainless steel drinking surface
  • Stainless steel under the lid
  • Note: There is a small bit of plastic on the handle for the splash guard, so remove that to completely avoid plastic contact
See Fellow
Healty Human's Stainless Steel Straw
Healty Human's Stainless Steel Straw
Healthy Human
  • Stainless steel drinking surface
  • Stainless steel straw included
  • Note the lid is plastic, so it can come into contact with your drink and mouth if you don't use the straw
See Healthy Human
Best Travel Mug for Cold Brew
Healthy Human's Straw for Iced Drinks
Healthy Human's Straw for Iced Drinks
Healthy Human
  • The only option I have that comes with a straw, which many people prefer using with cold brew
See Healthy Human
Zojirushi's Insulation for Keeping Ice
Zojirushi's Insulation for Keeping Ice
Zojirushi
  • Top-ranked insulation if you want to keep your cold brew ice-cold for as long as possible
See Zojirushi
Best Travel Mug with a Handle
Hydro Flask's Comfortable Handle
Hydro Flask's Comfortable Handle
Hydro Flask
  • The only option reviewed for this list that includes a handle, but it's a good one
  • Comfy, flexible 3-finger design that rotates out of the way so it's not cumbersome
​As mentioned before, this list did not include many popular mugs with side-mounted handles because those are more difficult to travel with (not cupholder friendly)
See Hydro Flask
Best Travel Mug for Arthritis
YETI Magslider's Easy-to-Open Slider Lid
YETI Magslider's Easy-to-Open Slider Lid
YETI Magslider
  • Easiest slider-style lid to open/close
  • Easiest to clean because the slider is magnetc and comes off
  • Durable to prevent major damage if dropped
  • Tapered, so it's easier to hold on the outside
See YETI
Worst Travel Mugs for Arthritis: YETI Hotshot or Commuter (have to twist hard to disassemble the lid for cleaning), Frank Green (complex lid design with many small parts), Hydro Flask Flex Sip (complex lid for cleaning, but better than the prior two), Owala SmoothSip (slider is tricky to use and disassemble if your hands have limited mobility or strength).
And Now...What is the Worst Overall Travel Mug?
Frank Green's Complex Lid (7 Parts, Many are Small)
Frank Green's Complex Lid (7 Parts, Many are Small)
Frank Green
  • The lid is incredibly complex and difficult to disassemble and put back together compared to the other options.  I cannot stress this enough.
  • The button does not work reliably, or at least it did not for me after extensive testing
  • Most expensive option tested​
See Frank Green

Part Two: Rapid-Fire Review of All 12 Travel Mugs Tested

All are vacuum insulated stainless steel between 16 and 20 ounces in size.
Top-Tier Options
These travel mugs have the best combination of a range of criteria and test results, making them a great fit for the widest range of people and uses.
YETI Magslider
YETI Magslider
YETI Magslider
Magnetic slider comes off easily
Magnetic slider comes off easily
YETI's Magslider is a relatively simple design that does a lot of things very well.

​It's a slider-style lid, and you simply push the slider back and forth to close the sip opening.  The bottle and lid are both dishwasher safe.

​Of all the travel mugs I tested, this one is the easiest to clean because the slider is magnetic, the rim seal is easy to remove and put back on, and there are no hidden or hard-to-reach spots.  Most people won't even need a brush and can handwash it for deep cleaning with just a sponge (it's also dishwasher safe).

It's also very durable, partially because YETIs seem to be more dent-resistant than many competitors, but also because the slider is magnetic.  This means it avoids problems like with Weto Weto or Owala's SmoothSip where the plastic connections with the slider might chip or break over time.

Couple these benefits with YETI's popularity as a brand (particularly for men), and there's a reason why YETI's Magslider is one of the most popular gift options.

YETI Magslider's only real downsides are the high cost and that they're leak-resistant, not fully leak-proof.
See YETI Magslider
Owala SmoothSip
Owala SmoothSip Slider
Owala SmoothSip Slider
Trickier than YETI's Magslider, but the Slider Comes Out
Trickier than YETI's Magslider, but the Slider Comes Out
Owala is the trendiest bottle brand on the market today.

​It's a slider-style lid, and you press down on the back side of the slider then push it backwards to open it.  The lid is explicitly dishwasher safe, but the bottle is handwash recommended to preserve the finish (though technically it's dishwasher safe too).

Like their FreeSip lid on their popular bottles, the drinking spout is ergonomic so it feels strangly good to sip from.  It's also raised, to the middle of the lid is less likely to bump against your nose when taking a sip.

Disassembling the lid for cleaning is pretty simple, but it can take some getting used to.  Just open the slider completely, pull up on the slider to pop it off, then you can twist the seal to remove it.  If you're having issue twisting the seal, give it a nudge to move it completely to the "open" position and you should be good.

The external lid threads also make cleaning the rim seal much easier compared to recessed seals that are harder to remove or put back into place.

Owala SmoothSip's main downside is that the slider is more difficult to open and close than other options like YETI's Magslider and you may find your finger slipping off the slider, especially if you just washed your hands.  Though in my experience, you get used to it and opening and closing this tumbler gets easier over time.
See Owala SmoothSip
Zojirushi
Zojirushi's Spring-Loaded Lid
Zojirushi's Spring-Loaded Lid
Zojirushi's Removable Spout
Zojirushi's Removable Spout
Zojirushi's travel mug has the best insulation by a significant margin, so if keeping your drink hot or cold is a priority, this is your best choice.

​It has a spring-loaded lid cover that opens by pressing a button on front.  The bottle and lid are not dishwasher safe.

Zojirushi has a lot of other great things going for it.  For a complex lid, it's incredibly well-designed for thorough cleaning and ease-of-use.  The lid cover goes over the spout to keep it cleaner throughout the day.  Also, the spout pops out so you can clean around it more easily, and the spout seal is also easily removable.

The lid cover includes a lock, and it's all very easy to use with one hand.  That along with the lightweight and narrow body makes this one of the easiest bottles to use for many people.

Zojirushi's main downsides are that the finish scratches easily and the bottom is more prone to denting if dropped compared to more durable options like YETI's Magslider.  The lid cover is also quite bulky, which can block your view more when driving, and while it's well-designed and easy to take apart, the lid still consists of many parts and surfaces that make cleaning more of a chore.
See Zojirushi
Fellow Carter Move
Fellow's Sleek Minimalist Design
Fellow's Sleek Minimalist Design
Stainless Steel under the Lid
Stainless Steel under the Lid
Fellow's Carter Move travel mug is one of the more attractive options on the market because of the aesthetic, minimalist design.  But besides the sleek look, it also has a range of other features that make it stand out.

It's a standard lid that you screw on-and-off to use, and it also comes with a splash guard that snaps into the rim and helps prevent spills.  The bottle and lid are not dishwasher safe.

This is one of the best travel mugs I've seen if you're goal is to avoid plastic contact with your mouth or drink because the rim is stainless steel as well as the bottom of the lid.  The splash guard handle has a bit of plastic, but you can use the bottle without the splash guard if you'd prefer.

Fellow Carter Move's main downside is that it's not a great travel mug for driving and commutes.  The standard lid is one more thing to juggle and potentially drop, leading to a dirty lid or worst-case causing a distraction.  And while the splash guard helps, this bottle still has the fastest flow and is most likely to accidentally splash in your face.  It's also not tapered and is one of the wider options I tested.
See Fellow
Mid-Tier Options
These are all solid options that many people use and they can excel at certain criteria, but in most cases there's at least one major drawback or they're not particularly exceptional overall.
Hydro Flask Flex Sip
Hydro Flask's Flex Sip
Hydro Flask's Flex Sip
Flex Sip's Lid's Interior Seal
Flex Sip's Lid's Interior Seal
Hydro Flask's Flex Sip is the only option from this list that includes a handle, but it's a really good one because it's Hydro Flask's classic, comfortable 3-finger design.

It has a twist-style lid where you turn the top to open and close the sip opening.  The bottle and lid are both dishwasher safe.

Hydro Flask designed this lid so it's relatively easy to disassemble for cleaning.  It involves a few parts and requires decent hand strength, but at least the parts are all a good size and durable (MUCH better than Frank Green).  Here's our Youtube Short that shows how it works.

Hydro Flask Flex Sip's main downside is that it has internal threads and the rim seal is recessed and difficult to remove and put back on for deep cleaning.
See Hydro Flask
Stanley Aerolight Transit
Stanley Aerolight Transit
Stanley Aerolight Transit
Transit's Plunger-Style Lid
Transit's Plunger-Style Lid
Stanley's Aerolight Transit is a jack-of-all trades travel mug that does a lot of things well without any major benefits or drawbacks.

It has a plunger-style (or lever-action) lid, and you pull up on the lid cover to drop down the seal.  The bottle and lid are both dishwasher safe.

Transit has good insulation, only trailing Zojirushi and Fellow and ranking similarly to YETI's Hotshot.  It also has a lightweight construction and narrow design that makes it easy to hold.  The lid doesn't take up much space or block your eyesight, just make sure to push the lid cover/lever all the way until it snaps back into the lid so it doesn't bump up against your nose when taking a sip.

Stanley Aerolight Transit's main downside is that the lid can be tricky to deep clean if you prefer to remove all of the seals.  The lid cover/lever is removable and that helps drop down the plunger seal more so the silicone seal is easy to remove, but it's a tight fit and tricky to put back on.
See Stanley
Simple Modern Voyager
Simple Modern Voyager's Push Button
Simple Modern Voyager's Push Button
You Can't Disassemble the Bulky Lid
You Can't Disassemble the Bulky Lid
Simple Modern's Voyager is one of the best options for driving and would be a top-tier bottle if not for one glaring issue, but first we'll look at the positives.

It has large button that you push to open and close the seal, and it worked reliably with a lot of testing.  The bottle and lid are both dishwasher safe.

You can also sip from any side, so you don't have to worry about lining up your mouth with a spout.  This along with the narrower design compared to other tumblers makes this a great option for when you're driving.

It also comes with a grip-pad ring on the bottom to prevent scratches.

Simple Modern Voyager's only real downside is a big one.  The lid is very bulky and not meant to be disassembled, making it nearly impossible to manually deep clean with brushes.  You'll rely on the dishwasher or soaking it with soap or Bottle Bright tablets, and then make sure it has time to properly air-dry.  But the fact that you can't disassemble it to check everywhere for mold or other buildup is a major drawback.
See Simple Modern
YETI Hotshot (soon-to-be Commuter)
YETI Hotshot
YETI Hotshot
Hotshot/Commuter's Two-Piece Lid
Hotshot/Commuter's Two-Piece Lid
YETI's Hotshot is essentially their standard Rambler bottles but with their Hotshot lid.

It's a twist-to-open lid, and you're able to sip from any side.  The bottle and lid are both dishwasher safe.

The lid is fairly easy to deep clean because you just twist the middle part until it pops out, and there are just two durable pieces involved.

YETI Hotshot has two main downsides. First is the overall weight and bulkiness compared to many other travel mugs without a handle to compensate, which makes it not a great option for driving or making it easy to bring with you.

Second is how you have to cram your fingers into a tight space to twist the lid opened and closed.  It's a pretty snug fit that requires some decent finger strength, and popping out the middle piece for deep cleaning takes even more effort.  This makes it a poor choice for most people with limited finger strength due to conditions like arthritis.
See YETI Hotshot
Worth noting is that YETI seems to be moving away from their "Hotshot" lid by taking the same design, rebranding it as the "Commuter" lid, and pairing it with a tumbler-style bottle similar to YETI's Magslider.  That last change makes it a better overall product, particularly for driving.
See YETI Commuter
Healthy Human Cruiser
Picture
Healthy Human Cruiser
Cruiser's Stainless Steel Straw with Silicone Tip
Cruiser's Stainless Steel Straw with Silicone Tip
Healthy Human's Cruiser is one of those travel mugs that doesn't try to do too much, and that makes it a decent option primarily for at-home use.

It has a press-fit lid with a permanent opening, so the lid is not intended to be leak-resistant or proof.  The bottle and lid are not dishwasher safe.

The main draw is that each Cruiser comes with a stainless steel straw, making it a great option for avoiding plastic contact with your drink, particularly for iced coffee.  The straw also comes with a silicone end to avoid that stainless steel taste some people experience.

Besides that, the rim is also stainless steel so you can sip there and avoid plastic contact, though that assumes you aren't using the plastic lid.

Healthy Human Cruiser's main drawback as mentioned is how you can't close it, so you're one accidental bump away from the tumbler tumbling off a desk and spilling your drink.
See Healthy Human
Bottom-Tier Options
These can serviceable, particularly for budget-friendly options.  But at some point you may want to upgrade.
Contigo Byron
Contigo Byron
Contigo Byron
The Plunger/Lever Style Lid
The Plunger/Lever Style Lid
Contigo's Byron is a budget-friendly option from a big-name, classic brand that can be serviceable for a daily-use travel mug.

It has a plunger-style (or lever-action) lid, and you pull up on the lever on top of the lid to drop down the seal.  The bottle and lid are both dishwasher safe.

The bottle includes a stainless steel bottom to prevent scratches, which is a good thing because the black finish scratches off very easily.  There's also a silicone grip around the middle of the bottle to keep your grip from slipping.

Contigo Byron's main downsides are that it has unremarkable insulation, the paint scratches easily, the lever action lid is not able to be fully disassembled for deep cleaning, and the interior lid threads make the rim seal more difficult to remove and replace for deep cleaning.

The lever-action lid also has a tight fit.  While good to prevent accidental opening, this can make it more difficult to open one-handed and you may need to turn the bottle first to line it up a certain way, particularly if you're driving.  And when you do that, you'll also likely find yourself pressing the palm of your hand against the sip opening and making that part more dirty.
See Contigo
Weto Weto
Visible Moisture Under the Slider
Visible Moisture Under the Slider
Chipped Plastic from the Slider when Removed for Cleaning
Chipped Plastic from the Slider when Removed for Cleaning
Weto Weto is the least-expensive option reviewed and is a capable travel mug.  It maintains a high ranking on Amazon because it's a budget-friendly alternative to YETI's Magslider in particular.

It's a slider-style lid, and you simply move the slider back and forth to open it.  The bottle and lid are both dishwasher safe.

Overall the design is quite simple and this travel mug is decent at most things, so it can be a good option as an every day mug.

Weto Weto's travel mug does come with a few significant drawbacks though.  I noticed visible moisture building up under the slider during regular use and cleaning.  However, the slider is not meant to be removed, and the small plastic connections can chip if you force the slider out of the lid.

​Also, the lid did not leak during my intial testing, but it started leaking after the drop test.  Not much, but it was dripping consistently possibly because the bottle or lid warped slightly.
See Weto Weto
Basement-Tier Option (Recommend Avoiding)
Very rarely do I straight-up recommend avoiding a particular bottle, but in this case I believe it's warranted.
Frank Green
Frank Green's Push Button Lid
Frank Green's Push Button Lid
Very Complex Lid Disassembly (7 Total Pieces)
Very Complex Lid Disassembly (7 Total Pieces)
Frank Green's travel mug was easily my least favorite option tested.

A few positives are that the push-button lid is a good concept when it works, and the bottle itself has a nice sleek, minimalist design.  The lid is dishwasher safe, though the bottle is handwash recommended (likely to preserve the finish).

However (deep breath)....
  • The button did not work consistently, often getting stuck and seeming to depend on how I pressed the button, like how many fingers I used and where exactly I pressed it.
  • The lid is ridiculously complex to disassemble and reassemble, involving 7 different parts (many of which are very small plastic parts that could easily be broken or lost).
  • The very thin metal rim may dent or warp more easily if dropped.
  • It's the most expensive option, at least in the US.
See Frank Green
Big thanks if you use a link to buy!  Those impartial referrals are what help me purchase every product tested and avoid direct sponsorships, all to help reviews like this continue to be completely unbiased.

Thanks again, and happy hydrating (and caffeine-ating).
0 Comments

Best Insulated Steel Bottle for Everyday Use? (Rankings for Insulation, Durability, and 7 More!)

7/7/2025

0 Comments

 
Best Bottle Rankings (Preview Showing Durability Criteria)
Best Bottle Rankings (Preview Showing Durability Criteria)
Update 9/20/2025: Check out our new Best Bottle Calculator!  It takes the information from this post and makes it even easier to find the bottles that are the best matches for your lifestyle and preferences.

This guide cuts through all the biased marketing to help you find the best insulated bottle that fits your lifestyle and preferences.  We'll specifically focus on bottles that are meant for general everyday hydration, so no fancy filter or infuser bottles here (but we have other guides that include those).  Don't worry though because you'll still see plenty of options, including 21 different stainless steel bottles and 1 plastic for comparison, each having its own strengths and weakensses.

Buckle up, and let's find your new favorite everyday bottle!

What's Next?

Part 1 - ​Rankings
Each bottle is ranked according to 9 different criteria, including:
  • Leak free?
  • Best insulation?
  • Most durable?
  • Easiest to clean?
  • Good handles?
  • Least cumbersome?
  • Affordable?
  • Car-friendly?
  • Most popular?
​Part 2 - Recommendations
The rankings help narrow the your choices, but it's still a lot of information to review.  And do you like a bottle that's easier to clean, or are you more concerned with durability?

To make it easier, try out our "Best Bottle" spreadsheet.  Enter which criteria are most important to you, and you'll get a list of bottles that could be the best match for your lifestyle and preferences.
Part 3 - Deep Dives
Once you've narrowed down the list, learn more about your top bottle options as one last check before you buy!

Video Review: Best Everyday Insulated Water Bottle Rankings

​​​​​​​​We also cover this in a YouTube video if you'd prefer to watch the recap!​

Disclosures
​BottlePro is part of the Amazon Associates and YouTube Referral Programs.  If you make a purchase using a link, we earn a small commission at no cost to you.  This is our main source of income and how we stay independent without sponsorships or paid ads, so big thanks if you use one!

Bottles Considered

Here's the full list, and I'll likely add bottles and update this post as I purchase more of them.
  • BruMate Era 40oz
  • Camelbak Chute Mag 32oz
  • Cirkul 32oz
  • EcoVessel 32oz
  • Fjbottle 32oz
  • Hydro Flask Standard Flex Straw 24oz
  • Hydro Flask Trail 32oz
  • Hydro Flask Tumbler 40oz
  • Hydro Flask Wide Flex Straw 32oz
  • Klean Kanteen TKWide 32oz
  • Nalgene 32oz
  • Owala Bottle 32oz
  • Owala Sway Tumbler 30ozamzn.to/4mIut3x
  • Ozark Trail 32oz
  • RevoMax 20oz
  • Simple Modern Tumbler 40oz
  • Stanley IceFlow 2.0 30oz
  • Stanley Protour 40oz
  • Stanley Quencher 40oz
  • S'well Original 25oz
  • Takeya Actives 32oz
  • YETI Rambler 36oz

Good Accessories for Most Large Bottles

Whether you go with Owala, Hydro Flask, YETI, Stanley, or one of countless other options, these are our two most recommended accessories for any large reusable bottle.
Bottle Brush Kit
Bottle Brush Kit
Bottle Brush Kit
​There are a lot of brush kits on Amazon at this point, so feel free to shop around.  This is the one I have, and it has a range of brush sizes that work with any bottle.
See Brush Kit
Cleaning Tablets
Cleaning Tablets
Bottle Bright Tablets
​I've tested these, and they work really well when cleaning out coffee and tea stains.  I also recommend using them roughly once per week during your deep cleaning routine.

For a less expensive option, consider using denture or retainer tablets.  But Bottle Brights aren't that expensive in the grand scheme of things if you're using one per month for your deep cleaning.
See Cleaning Tablets

Part 1: Best Bottles, Ranked by 9 Criteria

In this section, we'll run through each criteria according to the SABCD format, where "S" is the best and "D" is the worst.
Criteria 1: Which Bottles are Leak-Free?
​Let's start with an easy one, which bottles are leak-free?
Which Bottles are Leak-Free? (Rankings)
Which Bottles are Leak-Free? (Rankings)
Bottles that Leak
Stanley Quencher Leaking while
Leaking while "Closed"
Stanley Quencher
  • Easily the worst, and even leaks when "closed"
See Quencher
Hydro Flask Tumbler Leaking through Straw and Vent Hole
Leaking through Straw and Vent Hole
Hydro Flask Tumbler
  • Leaks less, but the press-fit lid may pop off if dropped
See HF Tumbler
Simple Modern Tumbler Leaking Through Straw
Leaking Through Straw
Simple Modern Tumbler
  • Leaks some, but not as much as Quencher
See Simple Modern
Bottles that are Leak-Free
All of the other bottles mentioned here are leak free, including Brumate, Camelbak, Cirkul, EcoVessel, Fjbottle, Hydro Flask Wide Flex Straw, Hydro Flask Standard Flex Straw, Hydro Flask Trail, Klean Kanteen, Nalgene, Owala, Owala Sway, Ozark Trail, Revomax, Stanley IceFlow, Stanley ProTour, S'well, Takeya, and YETI.
​
If you have issues with them leaking, check the seals to make sure they're clean and properly seated and that the spout or threaded connections are closed all the way.
​

​And notably, if you prefer tumblers with the large side mounted handles, Brumate's Era and Stanley's ProTour are good options with leak-free lids.
Brumate's Era is Leak-Free
Brumate's Era is Leak-Free
See Brumate
Stanley's ProTour Lid is Leak-Free
Stanley's ProTour Lid is Leak-Free
See ProTour

Criteria 2: Which Bottles have the Best Insulation?
​Now let's look at insulation, and there are some clear winners and losers.
Which Bottles have the Best Insulation? (Rankings - Cold Water Test)
Which Bottles have the Best Insulation? (Rankings - Cold Water Test)
Bottles with the Best Insulation
Camelbak Chute Mag
Camelbak
  • ​Classic and reliable
See Camelbak
Ozark Trail Bottle
Ozark Trail
  • Cheap but great insulation
See Ozark Trail
S'well Original
S'well
  • Routinely tests well
See Swell
Bottles with the Worst Insulation
Nalgene was technically the worst bottle in this review, but that makes sense because it's the only non-insulated bottle (included it for reference).

Of the vacuum-insulated dual wall bottles, the worst results were from:
Hydro Flask Tumbler
Hydro Flask Tumbler
  • Consistently poor compared to other similar insulated bottles
See HF Tumbler
Stanley Quencher
Stanley Quencher
  • Surviving a car fire doesn't mean it's the best
See Quencher
Stanley ProTour
Stanley ProTour
  • Same body design and mouth diameter as Quencher
See ProTour
Test Setup
  1. Filled this YETI cooler with ice water.
  2. Filled up each bottle using the cooler drain as a strainer to keep the ice out.  That way all the bottles started with water that was pretty much the same temperature, and we don't have to worry about variables like the amount of ice which are harder to control.
  3. Measured the temperature of the water in each bottle at the beginning, waited 24 hours, measured how much the temperature had risen, and recorded the difference.
  4. Repeated the test (once outside and once inside) and averaged the results.
Filling Each Bottle with Cold Water while Straining Ice
Filling Each Bottle with Cold Water while Straining Ice
Keep in mind there are A LOT of variables that determine how well a bottle insulates your water.  For an even deeper dive into this topic, check out this article.

You can also do a wide range of tests, including hot vs cold, ice vs no ice, same volume for each bottle vs filled to the top, and the list goes on.  Different test setups can yield different results, so you'll see different rankings on some of my previous tests.

But since it's summer, this post focused on my most recent cold water tests since.  Just don't forget to consider the bottle's mouth diameter since a small diameter bottle like S'well is not great for adding ice.

Criteria 3: Which Bottles are the Most Durable?
Now let's look at which bottles are most likely to last you 20 years instead of just two.
Which Bottles are the Most Durable? (Rankings)
Which Bottles are the Most Durable? (Rankings)
The logic behind the rankings can be admittedly tricky to follow.  For example, some bottles may have one feature that make them more durable (Owala's spout is fixed), while also having other features that drop them down the rankings (Owala's lid cover has small plastic parts and springs).  The rankings are my best attempt to take all these different factors into account based on observations, testing, and how each one feels in-person.  If you have any questions, feel free to reach out.
The Most Durable Bottles
YETI Rambler
YETI Rambler
  • Thicker steel makes it more dent-resistant
  • Simple lid without small breakable pieces
  • Classic steel finish is even better (fewer scratches)
See YETI
Nalgene
Nalgene
  • This post is primarly about stainless steel bottles, but if you REALLY want a dent-resistant option, consider going with Nalgene​
See Nalgene
The Least Durable Bottles
Cirkul, Marks
Cirkul, Marks
Cirkul, Cheap-Feeling Lid
Cirkul, Cheap-Feeling Lid
Cirkul
  • While Cirkul has a grip pad base that helps, it's still the least durable stainless steel bottle I've tested.
  • The bottle marks easily (though other finishes may be better).
  • Lid feels like cheap plastic.  Part of that is the flavor pod which is meant to be replaced often, but that's not a reason to give it a better ranking in my opinion.
See Cirkul
Factors Considered
Drop Test
Drop Test
Dent Resistance
Tailgate drop tests to see which bottles, boots, and bumpers prevent dents the best.
Scratch Test
Scratch Test
Scratch Resistance
Four light passes on 100 grit sandpaper to see how well the bottle's finish holds up.
Owala Sway - Lid Designs with Breakable Parts
Lid Designs with Breakable Parts
Lid Design
More smaller plastic parts and components like springs means more things that can break.
Boot or Grip Pad
Boot or Grip Pad
Bottle Boot / Grip Pad Included?
These offer protection, both from dents and scratches (boots protect the bottom rim better).
Straw Lids
In most cases, leak-proof straw lids are not a good choice if having the most durable bottle is important to you.  Straw bottles typically either have flip-up spouts or fixed spouts with a cover, and both have their own benefits and drawbacks.
Removing the Spout with Flip-Up Straw Lid
Removing the Spout with Flip-Up Straw Lid
Flip-Up Spout
  • Good: This common spout design is convenient
  • Bad: The spout can be difficult to remove for cleaning. They often rely on plastic connections that can wear out over time, making the spout fit more losely.  If it gets too loose, the spout might not close reliably and could leak.
Best Bottles with the Most Durable Flip-Up Spouts
Ozark Trail
Not as tight of a fit, so it may not get as damaged as you pop it in-and-out.
See Ozark Trail
Stanley ProTour
The newer removable spout with ProTour and IceFlow 2.0 is beefy.
See ProTour
Fixed Spout
Fixed Spout
Fixed Spout
  • Good: Avoids the problem of plastic connections for the spout wearing out.  Instead of the spout rotating down to seal, a cover goes over the top of the spout.
  • Bad: While these avoid the problem of flip-up spouts, lids like these tend to have springs and other parts that are more likely to break.
Best Bottles with Fixed Spouts
Owala
Owala Sway
Both of these are great for easy cleaning and avoiding flip-up spouts wearing out, but the lids have small parts and springs that can break if you drop your bottle.
See Owala
See Sway
Bottle Boot vs Grip Pad
Bottle Boot (EcoVessel)
Bottle Boot (EcoVessel)
Bottle Boots ("Bumpers")
  • Bottle boots are silicone covers that fit over the bottom of your bottle.
  • Don't fully prevent dents if you drop your bottle, but they can reduce the severity of them.
  • Prevent scratches, dampen noise, and protect surfaces your bottle is routinely on like a desk.
Bottles that Come with a Bottle Boot
Picture
See Takeya Actives
Picture
See EcoVessel
Grip Pad (Ozark Trail)
Grip Pad (Ozark Trail)
Grip Pads
  • Typically built into the base of the bottle, so they're not removable.
  • They also don't normally extend to the outer rim, so they don't offer as much protection as full boots.
  • However, they can still prevent some damage and scratches, dampen noise, and protect your desk.
Bottles that Come with a Grip Pad Base
Picture
See Fjbottle
Picture
See Ozark Trail
The bottom line is any stainless steel bottle can dent if dropped, but differences in the construction, lid, and finish can make one a better option than another if durability is your most important criteria.

Criteria 4: Which Bottles are Easiest to Clean?
Now let's look at how easy each bottle is to clean, which is very important but many people don't consider when buying.
Which Bottles are Easiest to Clean? (Rankings)
Which Bottles are Easiest to Clean? (Rankings)
Bottles that are Easiest to Clean
Hydro Flask Tumbler
Hydro Flask Tumbler (Exposed Straw)
  • Simplest lid design and a wide mouth make cleaning easier
  • Just a regular sponge and straw cleaner needed
See HF Tumbler
Nalgene
Nalgene (Standard Lid)
  • Maybe the simplest lid design you can dream up makes it straightforward to clean
  • But you'll need a bottle brush
See Nalgene
Takeya Actives
Takeya Actives (Chug)
  • Chug lids are a little more comples, but some are pretty easy to clean
  • Takeya's Actives comes with pull tabs on the seals
See Takeya
Owala Sway
Sway (Leak-Free Straw)
  • Easiest leak-proof straw lid to deep clean I've tested
  • Technically dishwasher safe (though rec'd hand-wash)
See Sway
Bottles that are Hardest to Clean
Stanley IceFlow 1.0
Stanley IceFlow 1.0
  • Non-removable spout makes this bottle difficult to clean
  • HIGHLY recommend going with their newer 2.0 version instead, so that's the one linked (has a removable spout)
See Iceflow 2.0
Brumate Era
Brumate Era and Revomax
  • Both of these have cool well-designed lids, but they are more complex
  • More intricate parts that are more tedious to clean
See Brumate Era
See Revomax
S'well Original
S'well (Original)
  • Extremely narrow neck helps with insulation, but it's too narrow for most bottle brushes (including the one I recommended)
  • Lid has a very narrow gap near threads, detailing brush needed
See Swell
Factors Considered
The rankings initially focused on which bottles are easiest to deep clean.  Then I adjusted that ranking up or down based on how dishwasher-safe both the bottle and lid are.
Deep Cleaning
Deep Cleaning
  • How easy is it to reach every surface?
  • How easy to completely disassemble and reassemble?
  • Wider mouth opening is easier to clean than narrow
Dishwasher Safe
Dishwasher Safe?
  • Are the bottle and lid dishwasher safe?
  • Not dishwasher safe?
  • Recommended handwash but technically dishwasher safe?
Pull Tabs
Pull Tabs
  • The seals are often tucked away and more difficult to clean, but some bottles like Takeya Actives and EcoVessel include pull tabs to make it easier
Mouth Diameter
Mouth Diameter
  • Wider means it's easier to clean, while really small mouth openings might not even let a bottle brush fit (looking at you S'well).
Deep Cleaning!!!
Cleaning Big Bottles (Ultimate Guide)
Cleaning Big Bottles (Ultimate Guide)
See Cleaning Guide
This is something most people don't do, and I'd bet 99% of people don't do as often as they probably should. 

If you use a reusable bottle every day, there's a good chance it's one of the dirtiest things you own, on par with your cell phone.  And bacteria and mold can build up over time, typically in the form of a thin, slimy biofilm.  Enough buildup and exposure over time could potentially leading to negative health effects.

That's why we generally recommend deep cleaning your bottle at least once every 2-4 weeks.  Ideally you'd do it even more often, but this timeline seems to be more achievable for most people and can prevent more widespread buildup of bacteria, mold, and biofilm.


A good brush kit and cleaning tablets make it a lot easier.  Here are the two I've used for the last few years.  You can also consider using denture or retainer tablets to save some money as they have very similar ingredients.
3-Brush Set (Bottle, Straw, and Detailing for Lid)
3-Brush Set (Bottle, Straw, and Detailing for Lid)
See Brush Kit
Bottle Bright Cleaning Tablets
Bottle Bright Cleaning Tablets
See Cleaning Tablets
Standard and Chug Lids
"Standard" Lid on HF Trail
Standard Lids
  • I call "standard" lids ones you have to screw all the way on-and-off, and they're the most traditional
  • Typically the simplest lids, so often are the easiest to clean
Hydro Flask's Flex Chug Lid
Hydro Flask's Flex Chug Lid
Chug Lids
  • Like standard lids, but with a narrower spout that makes sipping easier
  • Adds a spout cap and additional seal, so a little more complex to clean than standard lids
Straw Lids
Seal under Flip-Up Spout on Straw Lid
Seal under Flip-Up Spout on Straw Lid
Leak-free straw lids with flip-up spouts are often the most difficult bottles to keep clean.

​
There's always a seal under the pivot point that's notorious for building up bacteria and gunk.  For many people it's out-of-sight, out-of-mind.

You ideally should remove that spout to clean 100% of surfaces periodically, but as mentioned in Durability, that can lead to damage over time by wearing out plastic connections.
Leak-Free Straw Lids that are Easiest to Clean
Since leak-free straw lids are some of the most popular options on the market, some brands have made real improvements that make their bottles easier to keep clean.
Owala's Removable Seal
Owala's Removable Seal
Owala (any one with "FreeSip")
  • Easiest straw lid to deep clean
  • Avoids the flip-up spout problem
  • Removable seal for the spout cover
See Owala Bottle
See Owala Sway
ProTour's Removable Spout
ProTour's Removable Spout
Stanley ProTour and IceFlow 2.0
  • Removable spout and seals
  • Much better than IceFlow 1.0
See ProTour
See IceFlow 2.0
Hydro Flask Flex Straw's Removable Seal
Hydro Flask Flex Straw's Removable Seal
Hydro Flask Flex Straw
  • Removable insert makes it easier to clean around the pivot point, which helps a lot
  • However, the spout is still difficult to remove for 100% cleaning
See HF Flex Straw

Criteria 5: Which Bottles have the Best Handles?
Let's face it, big bottles like these can be a pain to bring with you, but having a good handle can make all the difference.
Which Bottles have the Best Handles? (Rankings)
Which Bottles have the Best Handles? (Rankings)
Bottles with the Best Handles
Stanley Quencher
Stanley Quencher
Side-Mounted Handles
  • Convenient and comfortable, there's a reason why these became so popular
  • Stanley's Quencher popularized it, but nearly every major brand has a tumbler like this today, including Hydro Flask, YETI, Owala, Simple Modern, Brumate, and many more
See Quencher
Stanley IceFlow
Stanley IceFlow
Top-Mounted Handles
  • ​Takes up less space than side-mounted handles while still offering a full-hand grip
  • These aren't as widespread as side-mounted handles, but some brands like Owala and Stanley are great options
See IceFlow
See Owala Sway
Fjbottle
Fjbottle
Carrying Strap
  • Fjbottle is unique because it has a rigid handle as well as a carrying strap
  • The strap is particularly helpful at times, like when your hands are full and you just want to loop a pinky through it
See Fjbottle
Bottles with the Worst Handles
S'well Original
S'well (Original)
  • No handle at all (they do have other bottles with handles though)
See S'well
Nalgene
Nalgene
  • Technically you can use the lid tether as a handle, but it's not exactly comfortable
See Nalgene
Cirkul
Cirkul
  • Very small and cheap, uncomfortable plastic design
See Cirkul
Factors Considered
Owala Sway, Full-Hand Grip
Owala Sway, Full-Hand Grip
How many Fingers Fit?
  • More is better
Cirkul, Tight and Uncomfortable with 2 Fingers
Cirkul, Tight and Uncomfortable with 2 Fingers
How Comfortable is It?
  • Like contoured plastic vs cheap sharp edges
  • Roomy vs crammed fingers?
Side vs Top
This is more of a preference, so it didn't play into the rankings for best handles (but it will in the next section).  But the handle design is noted in the Best Bottle Spreadsheet for quick reference to make things easier.
Side Handles
Side-Mounted
  • Rigid design that's typically more convenient for use around the house or office
  • Also easy to grab in the car
Top Handles
Top-Mounted​
  • Can be fixed or rotating
  • Better for longer walks or hikes, or if you want to clip it to a bag

Criteria 6: Which Bottles are the Least Cumbersome?
The overall size and weight of the bottle also plays a role in which one's a good fit for your lifestyle.  A good handle definitely helps, but maybe it's not a good fit in your car or you're looking for something that takes up less space on your desk.
Which Bottles are the Least Cumbersome? (Rankings)
Which Bottles are the Least Cumbersome? (Rankings)
​I thought about standardizing this part and picking all of the bottles that are closest to 32 ounces since the size bottle you get factors into how cumbersome it is, but I also wanted to focus on bottles I actually own and can test.  Also, this way the recommendations you'll get in the Best Bottle Spreadsheet are ones you've seen in this post.

So I ended up just adding notations to the chart so you can see how different volumes from different brands compare., but it's certainly a good idea to consider buying different size options of a certain brand if you like everything else about that bottle.
The Least Cumbersome Bottles
Hydro Flask Standard Mouth Flex Straw
Hydro Flask Standard
  • Hydro Flask's "standard" mouth is really their version of a narrow mouth bottle
  • This 24oz is slim and doesn't take up much space
See HF Standard Mouth
Revomax
Revomax
  • This 20oz bottle has a slim design and a handle that's pretty small and doesn't take up much space
See Revomax
S'well
S'well
  • While not having a handle is a downside in my opinion, there's no denying that S'well's Original bottle is very slim and great for use at a desk
See Swell
The Most Cumbersome Bottles
Simple Modern
Tumblers w/ Side Handles
  • While convenient, there's no denying that these large, rigid, side-mounted handles popularized by Stanley take up A LOT of space
  • Of the ones like this in this list, Simple Modern is the slimmest and lightest design so it's linked here
See Simple Modern
YETI Rambler
YETI
  • The price of having thicker, more durable steel is (a) actually having a higher price but also (b) being heavier and bulkier
See YETI
Klean Kanteen TKWide
Klean Kanteen TKWide
  • Has an "impact base cap," which is a metal cap on the bottom that gives more space between the bottom rim and the vacuum insulation
  • The idea is that large dents are less likely to break your bottle's insulation
  • Unfortunately, this also makes the bottle bigger and heavier
See TKWide
Factors Considered
This criteria is pretty straighforward, and the two main factors that I looked at were the weight and bulkiness of the bottle.

Criteria 7: Which Bottles are the Most Affordable?
Let's face it, 20 years ago, you'd have called me crazy if I said everyone would be walking around with +$35 bottles.
Which Bottles are Most Affordable? (Rankings)
Which Bottles are Most Affordable? (Rankings)
Most Affordable Bottles (Under $20)
Fjbottle
Fjbottle
  • Smaller brand, but a very functional bottle
See Fjbottle
Nalgene
Nalgene
  • ​Classic and reliable if you're OK with a plastic bottle
See Nalgene
Ozark Trail
Ozark Trail
  • Walmart's private label, so no wonder it's so cheap
See Ozark Trail
Most Expensive Bottles (Over $45)
Cirkul
Cirkul
  • Not as expensive at first, but it has the on-going cost of flavor pods
See Cirkul
Brumate
Brumate
  • The only leak-free lid with an exposed straw on top, but you'll pay for it
See Brumate
Hydro Flask Trail
Hydro Flask Trail
  • Lighter design, but typically more expensive than their standard bottles
See HF Trail
YETI Rambler
YETI
  • Set the bar with expensive coolers, and their bottles aren't cheap either
See YETI
The rankings are split like this:
Below $20: S
$20 - $30: A
$30 - $40: B
$40 - $45: C
Above $45: D

Each one is ranked based on the list price, but keep an eye out for price breaks because most of these brands run sales all the time or might be higher priced if they are low on inventory (especially with color drops).

The bottle volume also plays a big role in the price since bigger bottles cost more than smaller one of the same style, but like I mentioned in the previous section, this list sticks to bottles I actually own and that will show up in the Best Bottle Spreadsheet (though I'm planning to expand that spreadsheet in the future).

Criteria 8: Which Bottles are Car-Friendly?
For the commuters and road warriors, having a bottle that can stay secure next to you when on the road can be very helpful.
Which Bottles are Most Car Friendly? (Rankings)
Which Bottles are Most Car Friendly? (Rankings)
LEGAL DISCLAIMER
Be sure to check with your local laws to make sure sipping while on the go is OK since it counts as distracted driving in some areas
.  Even if it's legal where you live, it's a good idea to get a bottle or a cup holder adapter setup that will make staying hydrated in the car easier and safer.
Most Car-Friendly Bottles
Stanley Quencher
Stanley Quencher
Most Straw Tumblers
  • Tumblers are bottles with tapered sides that get smaller towards the bottom, letting them fit in cup holders
  • As long as the handle doesn't get in your way, it's hard to go wrong with these
  • Options in this list include Brumate, Hydro Flask's Tumbler, IceFlow, ProTour, Quencher, Simple Modern, and Owala's Sway
See Quencher
Hydro Flask Standard Mouth Flex Straw
Hydro Flask Standard Mouth Flex Straw
Hydro Flask's Standard Flex Straw
  • Narrow enough to fit in most cup holders
  • Straw lid that won't obstruct your view as much when taking sips
  • Doesn't have a large side-mounted handle that can get in the way
  • To clarify, Hydro Flask uses the term "standard" to refer to their narrow mouth design, while I typically call a "standard lid" any one that you screw all the way on and off
See HF Standard
Least Car-Friendly Bottles
YETI Rambler
YETI Rambler
  • Detatched spout cap is one more thing to juggle
  • Heavy, bulkier bottle can obstruct your view more
  • Larger diameter than similar sized competitors, so it's more likely you'll need an adaper
See YETI
Hydro Flask Trail
Hydro Flask Trail
  • Wide mouth bottle that  come with a "standard lid," meaning one you screw all the way on-and-off
  • That combination makes it more likely that you could drop the detached lid and/or spill water in your face
See Trail
Nalgene
Nalgene
  • This wide mouth bottle can also splash water in your face easily, but at least the lid is tethered to the bottle
See Nalgene
Factors Considered
Owala Sway's Tapered Base
Owala Sway's Tapered Base
Adapter Needed?
  • Most big bottles need adapters to fit in most cup holders
  • Smaller diameter bottles or tumblers (narrower towards the bottom) fit in a lot more cupholders without needing an adapter
Owala FreeSip Straw Lid
Owala FreeSip Straw Lid
Lid Type
  • Straw lids are typically the safest options for driving because you can take a sip without raising the bottle, keeping your vision less obscured and more focused on the road
  • Wide mouth bottles with standard lids (screw all the way on and off) are the worst because they are most likely to lead to spills
Takeya's Tethered Hinge Spout Cap
Takeya's Tethered Hinge Spout Cap
Tethered vs Non-Tethered Lid
  • Bottles with connected lids and spout caps are generally safer because it's fewer things to handle when driving
  • There's less potential to drop something that would get dirty or become a distraction
Need an Adapter?
BottlePro Max Cup Holder Adapter
BottlePro Max
  • Our company started by releasing the first adjustable cup holder adapter for big bottles in 2015
  • BottlePro Max is our newest version with a twist-to-expand base and centralizing tabs
  • More affordable option
See BottlePro Max
Swigzy Cup Holder Adapter
Swigzy
  • This is the premium option on the market, and as much as it pains me to admit it, they have a really good adapter
  • The top can be extended, and there are more centralizing tabs which can help with a wider range of bottle sizes
See Swigzy

Criteria 9: Which Bottles are the Most Popular?
How well-known the brand is can make be a real factor, particularly if you prefer to have a viral bottle or you're giving one as a gift.
Which Bottles are Most Popular? (Rankings)
Which Bottles are Most Popular? (Rankings)
The Most Popular Bottles and Brands (2025, USA Primarily)
These three are at the top of the water bottle world right now.
YETI Rambler
YETI Rambler
  • They've built overengineering and durability into their brand
  • Has very effectively kept its bottles as a premium option, while many other brands tend to have a couple years in the spotlight then fall off
  • Sterotypical Customer: Leans towards men
See YETI
Stanley Quencher
Stanley Quencher
  • Still massively popular and high sales on Amazon
  • Most other brands have begun offering Quencher-inspired bottles (tumbler base with a large, rigid, side-mounted handle)
  • Sterotypical Customer: Leans towards women
See Stanley
Owala FreeSip
Owala FreeSip
  • Overtaking Stanley on Google Trends in 2024
  • Colorways with quirky, fun combos, and at this point most other major brands have begun offering similar non-traditional color combos
  • Stereotypical Customer: Leans younger
See Owala
The Least Popular Bottles and Brands (2025, USA Primarily)
These are still great bottles in the right circumstances, and it's also important to re-state that this is just for the bottles in this post.  But these are not as widely-known or prestigious, so they may not be as good of options for gift-giving.
Fjbottle
Fjbottle
  • Not a big-name brand, just one I stumbled across
See Fjbottle
https://www.walmart.com/ip/Ozark-Trail-32-fl-oz-Black-Insulated-Stainless-Steel-Wide-Mouth-Water-Bottle-Loop-Handle-Flip-Lid/1159055913?wmlspartner=wlpa&selectedSellerId=0&wl13=1767&adid=222222222771159055913_117755028669_12420145346&wmlspartner=wmtlabs&wl0=&wl1=g&wl2=c&wl3=501107745824&wl4=pla-306310554666&wl5=9010117&wl6=&wl7=&wl8=&wl9=pla&wl10=8175035&wl11=local&wl12=1159055913&wl13=1767&veh=sem_LIA&gclsrc=aw.ds&&adid=222222222371159055913_117755028669_12420145346&wl0=&wl1=g&wl2=c&wl3=501107745824&wl4=pla-306310554666&wl5=9010117&wl6=&wl7=&wl8=&wl9=pla&wl10=8175035&wl11=local&wl12=1159055913&veh=sem&gad_source=1&gclid=Cj0KCQjw_qexBhCoARIsAFgBleucYM7dEHZZ5YX4P4SbhxaNEEdUb3vFwTn1ozGPgPlfViWqu-ZPLyoaAkmpEALw_wcB
Ozark Trail
  • Recognizable brand as Walmart's private label, but I don't think many people buy it specifically for the branding
See Ozark Trail
Revomax
Revomax
  • Great insulation and a cool lid, but not as widely-known
See Revomax
Factors Considered
This criteria is pretty hard to classify since different bottles are popular for different people, but I looked at a combination of places to come up with this list, which is my best attempt to rank them in an way that's unbiased towards any particular style, brand, or generation.
Google Trends
Google Trends
  • How are they trending over the last few years?
  • This can be tricky to account for everything, like "Stanley Cup" in hockey
Amazon Sales
Amazon Sales
  • Looking at the listing ranking or using an online tool like Junglescout to estimate total monthly sales
Social Media
Social Media
  • Looking through the number of subscribers and level of engagement

Part 2: Get Your Personalized Recommendations

​Now we have one more step to come up with your personalized recommendations.  If you click the link below, you'll see an Excel file on my Google Drive.

You won't be able to edit it while it's on my Google Drive since that would change it for everyone else too, so download it first then make your edits.
Best Bottles Spreadsheet (Google Drive)
The first tab "Start (Ranking)" looks like this and is where you'll enter how important each criteria is to you.
Rank Your Criteria (Tab 1)
Rank Your Criteria (Tab 1)
You know all those ranking charts from before?  This spreadsheet converts the tiers into numbers, with higher numbers being better.  Then it calculates a weighted total for each bottle by multiplying the tier numbers and your rankings for which criteria were most important.
Converting Tiers to Numbers
Converting Tiers to Numbers
Click the 2nd tab "Your Recommendations" to see something like this.

Click the sort button on "Total" (cell X7), then sort from largest to smallest. This re-arranges the list, and the bottles with the highest point totals are the best matches for you.
Recommended Bottle List (Tab 2)
Recommended Bottle List (Tab 2)
Review all the other info like the handle type to really hone in on what you'd prefer, and consider how different lids and sizes could change things too.

Then to
 see current pricing, click the hyperlinks on the "Link to Listing" column (column AG). Most go to Amazon, but Owala's Sway goes to Target and Ozark Trail goes to Walmart.

Comments:
  • It's just a simple Excel file and doesn't have any macros or programs in it, and if you're not comfortable downloading it this way, send me a message on bottlepro.net and I'll email it to you.
  • I tried it in Google Sheets, but the sorting function didn't work right when it converted. So it currently only works in Excel. I'm planning to add the Sheets version in the future.
  • This is just covering the everyday hydration bottles that I personally own, but there are THOUSANDS of other options. This is meant to be a great starting point to help you narrow your search based on what's important to you, but definitely shop around.  There are a lot of great brands out there that aren't even covered here.

Part 3: Deep Dives

After you've narrowed your search, check out the bottle's listing for more info.  You can also look at this other post, which focuses less on rankings for each criteria and more on the individual features for each bottle.
Our Biggest Bottle Comparison Yet
Our Biggest Bottle Comparison Yet
Best Bottles Comparison
This is our post that focuses more on details about each bottle instead of rankings and the Best Bottle Spreadsheet, so it's a great place to learn more about each individual option.  It includes the 22 bottles you saw in this post, as well as some others like filter bottles and infuser bottles.
See Post
Or if you've really narrowed it to just a few bottles, there are a couple links below.
  • IMAGE LINKS - See our info page for that bottle.  We're still adding some details like the latest cold water insulation tests, but they already contain A LOT of compiled useful information and most common questions (like measurements to check with your cup holder).
  • BUTTON LINKS - Most link to Amazon, but a few go to Walmart (Ozark Trail) or Target (Owala Sway) if it's not on Amazon.
Brumate Era 40oz
Brumate Era 40oz
See on Amazon
Camelbak Chute Mag 32oz
Camelbak Chute Mag 32oz
See on Amazon
Cirkul 32oz
Cirkul 32oz
See on Amazon
Picture
See on Amazon
Picture
See on Amazon
Picture
See on Amazon
Picture
See on Amazon
Picture
See on Amazon
Picture
See on Amazon
Picture
See on Amazon
Picture
See on Amazon
Picture
See on Amazon
Picture
See on Amazon
Picture
See on Walmart
Picture
See on Amazon
Picture
See on Amazon
Picture
See on Amazon
Picture
See on Amazon
Picture
See on Amazon
Picture
See on Amazon
Picture
See on Amazon
Picture
See on Amazon
Hope this helps, and happy hydrating!
0 Comments

Do Dented Bottles Still Hold Insulation?

4/19/2024

0 Comments

 
Do Dents Affect Your Bottle's Insulation?
Do Dents Affect Your Bottle's Insulation?

Do Dents Affect Your Bottle's Insulation?

​Today we're exploring the question, will a dent affect your bottles insulation?  Unless you have Spiderman-like reflexes, inevitably you will drop your bottle.  Plastic bottles like Nalgenes will be fine, but dual-wall stainless steel bottles are a different story.  Steel is a very strong and durable material for water bottle construction, but one major downside is that it is prone to denting.

​Many of these water bottles are not exactly cheap, costing as much as $50 for larger bottles from brands like YETI and Hydro Flask.  So if you've invested in a brand you love, you want to know that your insulation still works, right?

​The truth is that dents CAN affect your bottle's insulation, but it's not as simple of a question to answer as it may seem at first.  The location and size of the dent play a role, so there are more things to consdier than you might expect.

So today we're exporing the question, "which dents affect your bottle's insulation?"

Coming Next:
  • Reviewing why insulated bottles work
  • Cutting open bottles (for science!)
  • Insulation tests after dropping a bottle from greater and greater heights
The Inside of an Insulated Bottle (RevoMax)
The Inside of an Insulated Bottle (RevoMax)

Video Review: Do Dents Affect Your Bottle's Insulation?

I recently posted two videos about this test.  One that's a 3-minute recap of the most important details, and another that's a full-length 18-minute video showing more of the testing footage and general information about these types of bottles.  They each cover similar info as this post, so check those out if you'd prefer to watch the recap!
Longer Version (18-Minutes)
Shorter Version (3-Minutes)

How Do Dual-Wall Insulated Bottles Work?

Heat transfer through three primary methods:
  • Conduction (through contact between solid materials)
  • Convection (through the movement of fluids or air, like hot air rising)
  • Radiation (through visible and non-visible wavelengths, like sunlight)

​Dual wall bottles work so well because they have a vacuum between the two stainless steel layers.  Of the three heat transfer methods, only radiation is able to work through a vacuum.  So when you have an intact vacuum, you're able to limit heat transfer in (or out) of your bottle.

Another type of bottle you will see more and more commonly is what's normally referred to as a "triple-layer" bottle.  These types of bottles have the same general construction as dual-wall bottles, but they add a copper coating to the outside of the inner stainless steel layer.  The idea is that copper is better at limiting radiation heat transfer than steel, so this further improves the insulation properties of your bottle.

​To show you, I cut into a Hydro Flask (dual-wall) and a RevoMax (triple-layer with the copper coating).

Fun fact, in the video you can actually hear the air rushing in to replace the vacuum when I cut through the Hydro Flask!

The Inside of a Dual-Wall Bottle (Hydro Flask)
The Inside of a Dual-Wall Bottle (Hydro Flask)
The Inside of a Triple-Layer Bottle (RevoMax)
The Inside of a Triple-Layer Bottle (RevoMax)

Do Triple-Layer Bottles Work Better Than Dual-Wall Bottles?

While theoretically triple-layer bottles will have better insulation, I'm not convinced it makes a significant practical difference.  I recently did another insulation test that compared multiple triple-layer and dual-wall bottles, and the results suggested that the most important factors that determine how well your bottle insulates are:
  1. whether it's a narrow or wide mouth (narrow is better)
  2. whether the lid has insulation

Where Is The Worst Place On Your Bottle To Get A Dent?

From cutting open these two bottles, ​I found that the spacing between the two layers is much wider on the bottom compared to the sides.  So your bottle can have bigger dents on the bottom and still hold its insulation, which is probably by design because the bottom is the most likely place to get a dent.  But if you are unlucky enough to drop your bottle on its side onto a rock or something else that dents it there, then the dent doesn't need to be as deep to create a contact point between the two layers.
Approximate Spacing Between The Two Steel Layers In A 40oz Hydro Flask
Approximate Spacing Between The Two Steel Layers In A 40oz Hydro Flask

How Big Does A Dent Need To Be To Affect Your Bottle's Insulation?

It's not just the location of the dent, but also the severity that matters.
Insulation Failure A: Gradual Decrease
Smaller isolated dents can create contact point between the two steel layers.  Any contact point like this is going to be a pathway for heat transfer through conduction, so these dents can affect your insulation.  But the good news is that your bottle will still have good insulation around the majority of it, so it won't be a complete failure.
Small Dents Can Create Contact Points for Conduction Heat Transfer
Small Dents Can Create Contact Points for Conduction Heat Transfer
Insulation Failure B: Complete Loss (Vacuum No Longer Intact)
Worst-case, you might get a larger dent that cuts through the outer layer of steel. This allows air to enter the space between the steel layers to replace the vaccum, and then your bottle will be not better at insulating than a single-wall bottle.
Large And/Or Compound Dents Can Lead To Complete Insulation Loss
Large And/Or Compound Dents Can Lead To Complete Insulation Loss

Insulation Tests

​Next, I stress tested a RevoMax bottle by dropping it from increasing heights.  I did a 4 hour insulation test before the test and after each drop.

The bottle took A LOT of damage before the insulation was effected, even including some dents with extreme buckling and folding of the steel.

The bottle still had the same insulation after 12", 24", 36", and 48" drops.
Buckling From The 48
Buckling From The 48" Drop Full Of Water (Held Insulation)
Eventually the insulation was completely compromised (Failure B mentioned above) after the 60" drop.  This occurred when multiple dents with severe buckling overlapped, and that overlapping area is where there was too much repeated strain on the steel to the point that it cut through the outer layer.
Overlapping Dents After 60
Overlapping Dents After 60" Drop (Lost Insulation)
So the main reason the insulation failed is because the compound dents overlapped.  I wouldn't be surprised if the bottle would have held insulation after a single 60" drop.

Conclusion: Do Dented Bottles Hold Insulation?

In the vast majority of cases, YES!

​
​The bottom line is that you probably don't need to worry about your bottle's insulation being compromised by a dent.  Most dents, even really severe ones, are not large enough to affect the insulation.  Plus, the vast majority of people will replace their bottle before the insulation is affected because large dents can make the bottle sit wobbly, which is pretty annoying.

​But if you like to hang onto your bottles longer than the average person and you start to get overlapping major dents, that's when you would be more likely to start seeing your insulation get worse or potentially even competely fail.

Do Your Own Insulation Test!

​But if you have any doubts, do an insulation test.  Fill your bottle with the hottest water from your sink, measure the temperature, then let it sit for about 4 hours and measure it again.  If the temperature dropped less than ~10 degrees F, your insulation is still probably good.  More than ~10 degF and you might have a problem.
Doing An Insulation Test With Your Bottle
Doing An Insulation Test With Your Bottle

How Do You Protect Your Bottle's Insulation?

Other than never dropping your bottle EVER, there plenty of effective, easy options to keep your bottle protected and insulation as-designed.  Here are a few to consider:
  • Nuovo Adjustable Carrying Pouch
  • BottlePro's Neoprene Sling: https://amzn.to/3TMVrLF
  • Hydro Flask Bottle Boot: https://amzn.to/43ynstN
  • Hydro Flask Bottle Carrier: https://amzn.to/4ctTlHI​

Good All-Around Sling for Many Bottles
Nuovoware Adjustable Carrying Pouch for 25/32oz Bottles
Nuovoware Adjustable Carrying Pouch for 25/32oz Bottles
Nuovoware Adjustable Carrying Pouch for 25/32oz Bottles
  • Good storage
  • Adjustable strap
  • Draw-string top to help it fit more bottles securely
See on Amazon
Slings for 32 and 40oz Hydro Flasks
BottlePro's Neoprene Bottle Sling
BottlePro's Neoprene Bottle Sling
BottlePro's Neoprene Sling (Budget Option)
  • Good protection
  • Affordable
See on Amazon
HikerPouch Leather Bottle Sling
HikerPouch Leather Bottle Sling
BottlePro's HikerPouch (Leather Option)
  • Natural leather
  • Phone pouch
  • Leather conditioner included
See on Amazon
Bottle Boots
TFAKs Bottle Boots
TFAKs Bottle Boots
TFAKs Bottle Boots (5-Pack)
  • Inexpensive
  • Many options available (this is one of hundreds of listings)
  • Make sure you get the right size for your bottle
See on Amazon

Buying a water bottle?
Keep us in mind!

​See our Amazon store for helpful accessories, like fruit infusers, cup holder adapters, and carrying slings.
See Our Amazon Store
See BottlePro's Amazon Store
See BottlePro's Amazon Store
0 Comments

How Triple-Wall Bottles Work, and are They Worth the Hype? (Insulation Test vs Dual-Walls)

8/24/2023

1 Comment

 
Are triple-wall bottles better than dual-wall bottles?

Do Triple-Wall Bottles Really Have Better Insulation than Dual-Wall Bottles?

You’ve probably heard about dual-wall insulated bottles, but what about triple-wall?  If two walls are good, then three are better, right?  Let’s find out.

Dual-wall stainless-steel bottles have been around for a long time, and brands like Hydro Flask and YETI really launched them into mainstream use within the last decade.  Each bottle has two walls of stainless steel with a vacuum in between, and the lack of air reduces how much heat can transfer in or out.  We tested quite a few of these bottles for a video earlier this year, and that turned into one of our best-performing posts.
​
Triple wall bottles are not as widespread, but there are a few brands out there marketing this type of design, including S’well, RevoMax, EcoVessel, and Owala.  We didn’t discuss this type of bottle as we would have liked in our previous insulation test video, so we thought now would be a good time to revisit it, this time with a focus on seeing if the triple-wall design is worth the marketing hype.

Content Overview:

Here's what we'll cover in case you'd like to skip ahead to a certain point.
  • Link to our video review (covers the same info as this article)
  • How triple-wall and triple-layer bottles work
  • Insulation Test A (Using a uniform styrofoam cap)
  • Insulation Test B (Using the manufacturer's lid)
  • Comparing Test A and B
  • Conclusions​

Our Video Review

Our YouTube video covers the same information in this post, so click the link if you'd rather see the video.  Otherwise, keep reading the full post below!

Before we get started, there are a few details to point out.
  1. Hot vs Cold: In our previous video, we weighed ice before and after to determine how much of it had melted.  This time, we’re doing a hot-water test and using a thermometer to measure temperature.  We changed this up to try to make the test more reliable, and because insulation is the resistance to temperature change in either direction, it doesn’t matter if we’re testing hot or cold.  We should still get the same relative results and rankings for each bottle.
  2. Bottle and Mouth Size: Most of the bottles we tested hold 32 ounces, but we have a few other bottles that we wanted to test too.  We also had a couple of bottles that are narrow mouth instead of wide mouth.  For an ideal test, all of the bottles would have the same volume and the same mouth opening diameter. We’re a small channel that can only afford to buy so many bottles, so we’re working with what we have.  That being said, our results will still give you a pretty good idea of what to expect, especially if you’re looking for a 32-ounce size.
  3. Lid Design: Different lids have different insulating properties.  Because our primary goal is to test the insulation differences between dual and triple walls, we wanted to remove the variable of the lid design from our test.  More on this later.
  4. Triple-Wall vs Triple-Layer: finally, the term “triple-wall” is a bit misleading.  We’re going to spend a couple minutes geeking out about thermodynamics to explain how it works, so skip ahead if you’re like to move straight to the test.

How Triple-Wall Bottles Work

"Triple-Wall" vs "Triple-Layer"

Many people assume triple-wall means three walls of stainless-steel, but that’s not correct.  If you look closely at the marketing and listings, you’ll notice that it probably says “triple-layer” instead of “triple-wall.”  It’s a small but significant distinction because they don’t really have three walls.  They have the same dual wall construction with a vacuum in between, and the third layer refers to a copper coating on one of the stainless-steel walls.

From S'well's website:
“Thanks to our Therma-S'well® Technology and triple-layered insulation, which includes a copper layer, S'well products are able to keep any liquid hot or cold for long stretches, while maintaining a condensation-free exterior.”
Picture
You might be wondering how this would help.  Copper is known for being a good electrical conductor, but it also has a high thermal conductivity.  This means that heat is transferred very easily through it, so why would a copper layer help bottle insulation?

How Triple-Wall Bottles Limit Radiation Heat Transfer

​The answer comes down to the three basic types of heat transfer: conduction, convection, and radiation.
  • Conduction is the transfer of energy from one molecule to another through direct contact.  Matter is needed since you need the molecules to touch each other, so this is the type of heat transfer that the vacuum seal really helps with.
  • Convection is heat transfer related to the movement of a fluid such as water.  This does not apply as much to our situation since we’re focusing on sealed bottles.
  • The third method is radiation, and this is where the copper layer is designed to help.  Radiation is the transfer of heat by electromagnetic waves.  Examples include sunlight, light bulbs, irons, and toasters.
Type of Heat Transfer
Type of Heat Transfer
The key difference with radiation compared to either conduction or convection is that radiation does not need matter to transfer heat, which allows for radiation heat loss through the vacuum in dual wall bottles.

Emissivity: How Different Materials Allow Radiation Heat Transfer at Different Rates

Emissivity is a material property that indicates how efficiently heat is transferred by radiation.  A material with a lower emissivity value will transfer less radiant heat compared to a material with a higher value.  Copper has an emissivity of 0.05, so while the copper coating won’t do much to prevent heat conduction, it will help prevent heat radiation.  For reference, stainless-steel has a higher emissivity of 0.59, so the steel won’t prevent radiation heat loss as efficiently by itself.
Emissivity Table
Emissivity Table
So that’s the science behind the triple-layer and how it theoretically is better, but how does this translate into actual results and is it significant enough of a difference for you to consider when buying a bottle?  Let’s find out!

Insulation Test A - Uniform Styrofoam Cap

Insulation Test A (Using a Uniform Styrofoam Cap)

We looked at 14 total bottles.  11 bottles are dual-wall, and 3 have triple-layer insulation with the copper coating.
Dual-Wall:
  • Klean Kanteen 32-ounce TKWide Insulated
  • Hydro Flask 32-ounce Flex Straw
  • Hydro Flask 32-ounce Trail Series (lighter)
  • Takeya Actives 32-ounce (includes Matching Bottle Boot)
  • Camelbak Chute Mag 32-ounce
  • Ozark Trail 32-ounce
  • Steepware 22-ounce Tea Tumbler
  • FJbottle 34oz
  • YETI 36-oounce Chug Cap
  • Iron Flask 40-ounce
  • Stanley Quencher 40-ounce
Triple-Layer:
  • RevoMax 32oz
  • EcoVessel Boulder Series 32-ounce
  • S’well 25oz (the narrow mouth from this video)
We were originally going to boil water to recreate steeping tea or brewing coffee, but it would have taken quite a few batches and taken a lot longer.  So instead, we filled up each bottle with the hottest water from our sink.

As mentioned before, different lids have different insulating properties.  
Because our main goal was to compare the triple-layer vs dual-wall insulation, we wanted to keep the different lid styles from impacting the results as much as possible.  We purchased a sheet of Styrofoam insulation, cut it into a bunch of smaller pieces, and pressed them onto the rim of the bottles.  This created an impression in the Styrofoam pieces that helped limit the potential for gaps and temperature loss.​
Impression in the Styrofoam caps to limit heat loss
Impression in the Styrofoam caps to limit heat loss
We poked a hole through each piece of foam with our thermometer, and we used a few other smaller pieces of insulation to cover up the holes when we weren’t taking measurements. ​
Poking a hole through the cap
Poking a hole through the cap
Taking a measurement
Taking a measurement
Covering the hole when not taking a measurement
Covering the hole when not taking a measurement
Bottle lineup
Bottle lineup

Test A Results

We measured the temperature every hour for the next four hours, again around hour 8, and one more time around hour 20.  With each measurement, we inserted the thermometer through the hole in the Styrofoam cap until the temperature equalized.
​
This chart and graph show the percentage temperature change at different times during our test, which lasted 19 hours and 31 minutes.  Temperature drops ranged between 17.2% on the low end to 27.0% on the high end.  Looking closer at the data, there are a few interesting results to note.
Test A Results: Table
Test A Results: Table
Test A Results: Graph
Test A Results: Graph
Two of the triple-layer bottles, RevoMax and S’well, had the best results.  The third triple-layer bottle, EcoVessel, didn’t fare as well, but it was still in the top five.

The best dual-wall bottle really surprised us.  Ozark Trail, the Walmart brand bottle that we bought for $11, had an 18.5% temperature loss.  Compare that to 20.9% for a $50 YETI Rambler and 24.2% for a $45 Hydro Flask.
​
The worst bottle by a wide margin is Steepware, which is a bit ironic given that it’s primarily made for brewing tea.  That being said, it’s probably not a major concern because most people will drink the tea within a few hours before it goes stale.

So based on the results, it does appear that the copper layer may have an impact and helps insulation.  However, depending on which brands you’re comparing, the difference between triple layer and dual wall insulation might not be as great as you would have thought.  When you average the percent temperature loss for dual wall vs triple layer bottles, you get 22.7% and 18.3% respectively.  A 5% difference over 20 hours is significant, but it’s not really game-changing in our opinion.

However, there’s another big variable that makes this conclusion a bit uncertain.  We can’t afford to buy every type of bottle, and it just so happens with our bottle collection that the two best performing bottles were also our only two narrow mouth bottles.  Because most heat is lost through the lid and mouth opening, narrow mouth bottles should have an advantage over wide mouth ones.  We’d like to do another test in the future that focuses on wide-mouth vs narrow-mouth insulation once we have more narrow mouth bottles to compare.

Insulation Test B: Manufacturer's Lid
Insulation Test B: Manufacturer's Lid

Insulation Test B (Using the Manufacturer's Lid)

But let’s face it, you’re not going to be walking around with one of these bottles with a Styrofoam cap.  We did the test first because we wanted to isolate the effect that the copper layer has on the insulation, but the more practical test that you can use compares the bottles when using the lids that they come with.  So we ran a 2nd version of the test using the bottle lids.

For each measurement, we swapped the bottle lid with the Styrofoam piece from the previous test.  Then we pushed the thermometer through the Styrofoam, and this prevented excessive temperature loss for the 15-20 seconds that we needed for each measurement.  Once we had the reading, we put the normal cap back on.
Test B using the manufacturer's lids
Test B using the manufacturer's lids
Swapping the manufacturer's lid for the Styrofoam cap for each measurement
Swapping the manufacturer's lid for the Styrofoam cap for each measurement
Taking a measurement through the Styrofoam cap
Taking a measurement through the Styrofoam cap

Test B Results

​This test lasted for 19 hours and 17 minutes, and we made the same type of chart and table to show the results.  Right away, there are some interesting data points and details to unpack.
Test B Results: Table
Test B Results: Table
Test B Results: Graph
Test B Results: Graph
The relative rankings were mostly the same as with Test A, but there was a much wider range of results with a 13.5% temperature drop on the low end to 30.1% on the high end.  That’s an increase in the range of results from 9.8% with Test A to 16.6% with Test B.

The same two brands performed the best (RevoMax and S'well), but they widened their lead significantly.  However, keep in mind that these are the only two narrow-mouth bottles in our test.

Ozark Trail had a great showing again, and this was the best dual-wall bottle in both tests.
​
Unfortunately for Steepware, this bottle was even more of an outlier on the wrong side of the average compared to Test A.

Test A vs Test B: Did the Manufacturer's Lid Help?
Test A vs Test B: Did the Manufacturer's Lid Help?

Does the Bottle Manufacturer's Lid Help Insulation?

​While the relative rankings were similar for both tests, you may have noticed the rankings did change in some cases.  For example, Hydro Flask’s Trail Series jumped from the 2nd worst with Test A to the middle of the pack with Test B.  Since the only change between the two tests was that we switched from the standardized foam pieces to each brand’s lid, any changes in the rankings means that some brands have designed lids with better insulation than others.
Standardizing the Results
Tests A and B had slightly different total durations, so to better illustrate how the results for each bottle changed between the tests, we needed to standardize the results.  We calculated the temperature drop per minute over the duration of both tests, then we multiplied that by 1200 to simulate a 20-hour test.  Then we compared Test A vs Test B for each brand, and this graph shows how each brand changed.
Test A vs Test B Comparison
Test A vs Test B Comparison
​Bottles that fall on the left side had better results with their brand’s lids instead of the Styrofoam cap, and bottles on the right did better with the Styrofoam.  
Bottles whose Manufacturer's Lid Helped Insulation Compared to the Styrofoam Cap
Bottles whose Manufacturer's Lid Helped Insulation Compared to the Styrofoam Cap
​S’well, RevoMax, and both Hydro Flasks were the only bottles that improved with Test B.  When you look at the lids with each of these bottles, you can see that they seem to have more built-in insulation, like with S'well and RevoMax.
S'well lid insulation
S'well lid insulation
RevoMax lid insulation
RevoMax lid insulation
Most of the other bottle lids like Steepware and Takeya don’t have built-in insulation and just have single layer plastic construction in the cap, so it’s understandable that they didn’t fare as well. ​
Steepware lid insulation
Steepware lid insulation
Takeya lid insulation
Takeya lid insulation

Conclusions: Are Triple-Wall Bottles Worth the Hype?

​So when we take a step back and look at the results as a whole, we have a few main takeaways.
  1. Triple-Layer vs Dual-Wall: Triple-layer construction does seem to help compared to dual-wall insulation, but it may not be as big of a difference-maker on its own as the marketing might make you think.
  2. Lid Design and Narrow vs Wide Mouth: The more significant factor appears to be narrow vs wide mouth and the insulating properties of each brand’s lid design.
  3. Price: Price doesn’t guarantee results, as Ozark’s $11 bottle did better than all the other dual-wall bottles, including YETI and Hydro Flask.
​Based on these results, we have a few more video ideas that we may work on in the near future.  Once we have more narrow-mouth bottles in our collection, we want to compare those against wide-mouth bottles.  We also think it would be interesting to focus on premium brands vs budget brands, because let’s face it, we’re probably not the only ones that were surprised that Ozark Trail outperformed YETI.  And finally, we only ran one instance of each test, and for more reliable comparisons and data, we ideally would repeat the test more times and average the results.

Buying a Large Bottle?  Keep Us in Mind!

Check out our Amazon store for fun and helpful accessories, like fruit infusers, cup holder adapters, and carrying slings.
Picture
BottlePro's Amazon Store
1 Comment
    Follow us for more hydration-focused updates!

    Try searching for things like "infusers" or "Hydro Flask".


    Categories

    All
    Bottle Cleaning
    Bottle Protection
    Bottles
    Bottle Slings
    Coffee
    Cup Holders
    Environment
    Filters
    Fruit Infusers
    Healthy Lifestyle
    Hiking
    Hydration Products
    Hydro Flasks
    Ice
    Insulation
    Iron Flasks
    Klean Kanteens
    Lead
    Mason Jars
    Microplastics
    Mugs
    Owala
    PFAS
    Plastic Free
    Smart Mug
    Soda Habit
    Splash Guards
    Stanley
    Tea
    Weight Loss
    YETI

    Archives

    November 2025
    October 2025
    September 2025
    July 2025
    May 2025
    April 2025
    March 2025
    February 2025
    January 2025
    December 2024
    September 2024
    July 2024
    June 2024
    May 2024
    April 2024
    March 2024
    February 2024
    December 2023
    October 2023
    August 2023
    July 2023
    June 2023
    May 2023
    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022


    Amazon Associates Program

    BottlePro is part of the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program.  We strive to provide helpful information and product recommendations, and we receive a commission on purchases made after you click through our links.
Contact Us/Returns
Refund Policy
Shipping Policy
Wholesale Inquiries
Privacy Policy
Terms of Service
PS Kreative, LLC, Licensed in North Carolina, USA (ID # 2514262), DBA "BottlePro", ​Copyright PS Kreative LLC © 2025
  • Home
  • Learn
    • Best Bottle Calculator
    • Comparisons and Insulation Tests
    • Health and Hydration
    • Sip or Skip (Individual Bottles) >
      • Bottles >
        • Camelbak
        • EcoVessel
        • Fjbottle
        • Healthy Human
        • Hydro Flask >
          • Hydro Flask Standard
          • Hydro Flask Trail
          • Hydro Flask Wide
        • Iron Flask
        • Klean Kanteen TKWide
        • Nalgene
        • Owala FreeSip
        • Ozark Trail
        • RevoMax
        • S'well Original
        • Takeya
        • ThermoFlask
        • YETI Rambler
      • Tumblers >
        • Brumate Era
        • Hydro Flask
        • Owala FreeSip Sway
        • Simple Modern
        • Stanley >
          • Stanley Quencher
          • Stanley IceFlow
          • Stanley ProTour
      • Specialty Bottles (Filters, Infusing) >
        • Brita (Filter)
        • Cirkul (Infusing)
        • GRAYL (Filter)
        • LARQ (UV)
        • Stanley Thermos (Insulation)
        • Steepware (Infusing)
        • Vesmoon (Infusing)
        • Vitaloop (Filter)
        • Zulu Ace (Removable Base)
  • Shop
    • Cup Holder Adapter
    • Infusers >
      • FlavorFuze Pod
      • FlavorFuze Straw
      • FlavorFuze Steel
    • Splash Guard
  • Demos
  • Hydration Blog
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Find a Store