What is the Best Travel Mug for Coffee and Tea?If you're wondering what is the best travel mug, you're not alone. There are thousands of travel mugs, tumblers, and coffee bottles on the market today, so it can be a big overwhelming. The good news is that I've collected, tested, and overanalyzed many of the most of the popular brands over the years for this business, and today I'll show you my full collection to help you find the best travel mug for your preferences and lifestyle. Depending on where you look, this type of bottle may also be called "travel tumblers," "travel bottles," or "coffee bottles." Because this post focuses on mugs and tumblers that are easier for traveling, ones with side-mounted handles are not included because they are not as compatible with many cupholders. But we'll have a separate post focusing on those soon! What's Next?
Video Review: What is the Best Travel Mug?This video goes into even more detail and analysis about each bottle by ranking them all according to 12 different criteria, so check this out for an even deeper dive! Good Accessories for Most Travel MugsWhether you go with Fellow, Stanley, YETI, or Zojirushi, these are two fo our most popular recommended accessories that help make cleaning any big reusable bottle much easier.
Part One: Recommended by UseDifferent travel mugs are better for different situations, so here let's take a look at various uses to see which bottle is the best option. Scroll down to Part Two to read more about any particular brand or bottle. Best Travel Mug for Everyday, All-Around Use These are the two travel mugs I've recently found myself going back to most regularly when I'm not deliberately testing a new one. They each have a great combination of features that make them outstanding options for everyday use.
Worst Travel Mug for Everyday Use: Frank Green (more on this further down) Best Travel Mug for Value
Best Travel Mug for Driving, Commutes, and Road Trips
Honorable Mention: Stanley Aerolight Transit (narrow design, lid cover pushes all the way back to stay out of your view), Owala SmoothSip (tapered for cupholders, one-handed open/close) Worst Travel Mugs for Driving: Fellow Carter Move (2-handed open/close, wider base than most, lid isn't tethered, wide mouth with the fastest flow even with the splash guard inserted), YETI Hotshot (very bulky, 2-handed open/close) Best Travel Mugs with Ceramic Lined Interiors
Best Travel Mug for Insulation
Honorable Mentions: Stanley Aerolight Transit and YETI Hotshot Worst Travel Mugs for Insulation: With vacuum insulated bottles, most heat transfers through the lid. That's why a general rule-of-thumb is that bottles with wider rims have worse insulation. This includes traditional tumblers like YETI's Magslider, Healthy Human's Cruiser, Owala's SmoothSip, Simple Modern's Voyager, and Weto Weto's tumbler. Best Travel Mug for Home or Office
Honorable Mention: Hydro Flask Flex Sip (has a handle that you can grab with one finger when holding other things, like if you're carrying several things and your bottle to a meeting), Stanley Aerolight Transit (good combination of small diameter to take up less space, lightweight, and good insulation) Worst Travel Mugs for Home or Office: YETI Hotshot (very large and bulky with no handle) Best Travel Mug for Easy Cleaning
Honorable Mention: Zojirushi (for a complex lid it's well-designed and surprisingly easy to clean, but you'll want several brush sizes from a kit like this one) Worst Travel Mugs for Easy Cleaning: Frank Green (ridiculously complex to disassemble the lid) and Simple Modern Voyager (unable to disassemble the lid) Best Travel Mug for Clumsy People (Most Durable)
Least Durable Travel Mugs: Frank Green (many small plastic parts), Zojirushi (scratches easily), Weto Weto (slider is hard to clean around without damaging the plastic connection) The Most Popular Travel Mugs and Best to Give as a Gift
Best Travel Mug for Safety and Limiting Plastic Contact
Best Travel Mug for Cold Brew
Best Travel Mug with a Handle
Best Travel Mug for Arthritis
Worst Travel Mugs for Arthritis: YETI Hotshot or Commuter (have to twist hard to disassemble the lid for cleaning), Frank Green (complex lid design with many small parts), Hydro Flask Flex Sip (complex lid for cleaning, but better than the prior two), Owala SmoothSip (slider is tricky to use and disassemble if your hands have limited mobility or strength). And Now...What is the Worst Overall Travel Mug?
Part Two: Rapid-Fire Review of All 12 Travel Mugs TestedAll are vacuum insulated stainless steel between 16 and 20 ounces in size. Top-Tier Options These travel mugs have the best combination of a range of criteria and test results, making them a great fit for the widest range of people and uses. YETI Magslider
Owala SmoothSip
Zojirushi
Fellow Carter Move
Mid-Tier Options These are all solid options that many people use and they can excel at certain criteria, but in most cases there's at least one major drawback or they're not particularly exceptional overall. Hydro Flask Flex Sip
Stanley Aerolight Transit
Simple Modern Voyager
YETI Hotshot (soon-to-be Commuter)
Healthy Human Cruiser
Bottom-Tier Options These can serviceable, particularly for budget-friendly options. But at some point you may want to upgrade. Contigo Byron
Weto Weto
Basement-Tier Option (Recommend Avoiding) Very rarely do I straight-up recommend avoiding a particular bottle, but in this case I believe it's warranted. Frank Green
Big thanks if you use a link to buy! Those impartial referrals are what help me purchase every product tested and avoid direct sponsorships, all to help reviews like this continue to be completely unbiased.
Thanks again, and happy hydrating (and caffeine-ating).
0 Comments
Best Insulated Steel Bottle for Everyday Use? (Rankings for Insulation, Durability, and 7 More!)7/7/2025 Update 9/20/2025: Check out our new Best Bottle Calculator! It takes the information from this post and makes it even easier to find the bottles that are the best matches for your lifestyle and preferences. This guide cuts through all the biased marketing to help you find the best insulated bottle that fits your lifestyle and preferences. We'll specifically focus on bottles that are meant for general everyday hydration, so no fancy filter or infuser bottles here (but we have other guides that include those). Don't worry though because you'll still see plenty of options, including 21 different stainless steel bottles and 1 plastic for comparison, each having its own strengths and weakensses. Buckle up, and let's find your new favorite everyday bottle! What's Next?
Video Review: Best Everyday Insulated Water Bottle RankingsWe also cover this in a YouTube video if you'd prefer to watch the recap! Disclosures BottlePro is part of the Amazon Associates and YouTube Referral Programs. If you make a purchase using a link, we earn a small commission at no cost to you. This is our main source of income and how we stay independent without sponsorships or paid ads, so big thanks if you use one! Bottles ConsideredHere's the full list, and I'll likely add bottles and update this post as I purchase more of them.
Good Accessories for Most Large BottlesWhether you go with Owala, Hydro Flask, YETI, Stanley, or one of countless other options, these are our two most recommended accessories for any large reusable bottle.
Part 1: Best Bottles, Ranked by 9 CriteriaIn this section, we'll run through each criteria according to the SABCD format, where "S" is the best and "D" is the worst. Criteria 1: Which Bottles are Leak-Free? Let's start with an easy one, which bottles are leak-free? Bottles that Leak
Bottles that are Leak-Free All of the other bottles mentioned here are leak free, including Brumate, Camelbak, Cirkul, EcoVessel, Fjbottle, Hydro Flask Wide Flex Straw, Hydro Flask Standard Flex Straw, Hydro Flask Trail, Klean Kanteen, Nalgene, Owala, Owala Sway, Ozark Trail, Revomax, Stanley IceFlow, Stanley ProTour, S'well, Takeya, and YETI. If you have issues with them leaking, check the seals to make sure they're clean and properly seated and that the spout or threaded connections are closed all the way. And notably, if you prefer tumblers with the large side mounted handles, Brumate's Era and Stanley's ProTour are good options with leak-free lids. Criteria 2: Which Bottles have the Best Insulation? Now let's look at insulation, and there are some clear winners and losers. Bottles with the Best Insulation
Bottles with the Worst Insulation Nalgene was technically the worst bottle in this review, but that makes sense because it's the only non-insulated bottle (included it for reference). Of the vacuum-insulated dual wall bottles, the worst results were from:
Keep in mind there are A LOT of variables that determine how well a bottle insulates your water. For an even deeper dive into this topic, check out this article. You can also do a wide range of tests, including hot vs cold, ice vs no ice, same volume for each bottle vs filled to the top, and the list goes on. Different test setups can yield different results, so you'll see different rankings on some of my previous tests. But since it's summer, this post focused on my most recent cold water tests since. Just don't forget to consider the bottle's mouth diameter since a small diameter bottle like S'well is not great for adding ice. Criteria 3: Which Bottles are the Most Durable? Now let's look at which bottles are most likely to last you 20 years instead of just two. The logic behind the rankings can be admittedly tricky to follow. For example, some bottles may have one feature that make them more durable (Owala's spout is fixed), while also having other features that drop them down the rankings (Owala's lid cover has small plastic parts and springs). The rankings are my best attempt to take all these different factors into account based on observations, testing, and how each one feels in-person. If you have any questions, feel free to reach out. The Most Durable Bottles
The Least Durable Bottles Cirkul
Factors Considered Straw Lids In most cases, leak-proof straw lids are not a good choice if having the most durable bottle is important to you. Straw bottles typically either have flip-up spouts or fixed spouts with a cover, and both have their own benefits and drawbacks.
Bottle Boot vs Grip Pad
The bottom line is any stainless steel bottle can dent if dropped, but differences in the construction, lid, and finish can make one a better option than another if durability is your most important criteria. Criteria 4: Which Bottles are Easiest to Clean? Now let's look at how easy each bottle is to clean, which is very important but many people don't consider when buying. Bottles that are Easiest to Clean
Bottles that are Hardest to Clean
Factors Considered The rankings initially focused on which bottles are easiest to deep clean. Then I adjusted that ranking up or down based on how dishwasher-safe both the bottle and lid are.
Deep Cleaning!!!
A good brush kit and cleaning tablets make it a lot easier. Here are the two I've used for the last few years. You can also consider using denture or retainer tablets to save some money as they have very similar ingredients. Standard and Chug Lids
Straw Lids
Leak-Free Straw Lids that are Easiest to Clean Since leak-free straw lids are some of the most popular options on the market, some brands have made real improvements that make their bottles easier to keep clean.
Criteria 5: Which Bottles have the Best Handles? Let's face it, big bottles like these can be a pain to bring with you, but having a good handle can make all the difference. Bottles with the Best Handles
Bottles with the Worst Handles
Factors Considered Side vs Top This is more of a preference, so it didn't play into the rankings for best handles (but it will in the next section). But the handle design is noted in the Best Bottle Spreadsheet for quick reference to make things easier. Criteria 6: Which Bottles are the Least Cumbersome? The overall size and weight of the bottle also plays a role in which one's a good fit for your lifestyle. A good handle definitely helps, but maybe it's not a good fit in your car or you're looking for something that takes up less space on your desk. I thought about standardizing this part and picking all of the bottles that are closest to 32 ounces since the size bottle you get factors into how cumbersome it is, but I also wanted to focus on bottles I actually own and can test. Also, this way the recommendations you'll get in the Best Bottle Spreadsheet are ones you've seen in this post. So I ended up just adding notations to the chart so you can see how different volumes from different brands compare., but it's certainly a good idea to consider buying different size options of a certain brand if you like everything else about that bottle. The Least Cumbersome Bottles
The Most Cumbersome Bottles
Factors Considered This criteria is pretty straighforward, and the two main factors that I looked at were the weight and bulkiness of the bottle. Criteria 7: Which Bottles are the Most Affordable? Let's face it, 20 years ago, you'd have called me crazy if I said everyone would be walking around with +$35 bottles. Most Affordable Bottles (Under $20)
Most Expensive Bottles (Over $45)
The rankings are split like this: Below $20: S $20 - $30: A $30 - $40: B $40 - $45: C Above $45: D Each one is ranked based on the list price, but keep an eye out for price breaks because most of these brands run sales all the time or might be higher priced if they are low on inventory (especially with color drops). The bottle volume also plays a big role in the price since bigger bottles cost more than smaller one of the same style, but like I mentioned in the previous section, this list sticks to bottles I actually own and that will show up in the Best Bottle Spreadsheet (though I'm planning to expand that spreadsheet in the future). Criteria 8: Which Bottles are Car-Friendly? For the commuters and road warriors, having a bottle that can stay secure next to you when on the road can be very helpful. LEGAL DISCLAIMER Be sure to check with your local laws to make sure sipping while on the go is OK since it counts as distracted driving in some areas. Even if it's legal where you live, it's a good idea to get a bottle or a cup holder adapter setup that will make staying hydrated in the car easier and safer. Most Car-Friendly Bottles
Least Car-Friendly Bottles
Factors Considered
Need an Adapter?
Criteria 9: Which Bottles are the Most Popular? How well-known the brand is can make be a real factor, particularly if you prefer to have a viral bottle or you're giving one as a gift. The Most Popular Bottles and Brands (2025, USA Primarily) These three are at the top of the water bottle world right now.
The Least Popular Bottles and Brands (2025, USA Primarily) These are still great bottles in the right circumstances, and it's also important to re-state that this is just for the bottles in this post. But these are not as widely-known or prestigious, so they may not be as good of options for gift-giving.
Factors Considered This criteria is pretty hard to classify since different bottles are popular for different people, but I looked at a combination of places to come up with this list, which is my best attempt to rank them in an way that's unbiased towards any particular style, brand, or generation.
Part 2: Get Your Personalized RecommendationsNow we have one more step to come up with your personalized recommendations. If you click the link below, you'll see an Excel file on my Google Drive. You won't be able to edit it while it's on my Google Drive since that would change it for everyone else too, so download it first then make your edits. The first tab "Start (Ranking)" looks like this and is where you'll enter how important each criteria is to you. You know all those ranking charts from before? This spreadsheet converts the tiers into numbers, with higher numbers being better. Then it calculates a weighted total for each bottle by multiplying the tier numbers and your rankings for which criteria were most important. Click the 2nd tab "Your Recommendations" to see something like this. Click the sort button on "Total" (cell X7), then sort from largest to smallest. This re-arranges the list, and the bottles with the highest point totals are the best matches for you. Review all the other info like the handle type to really hone in on what you'd prefer, and consider how different lids and sizes could change things too. Then to see current pricing, click the hyperlinks on the "Link to Listing" column (column AG). Most go to Amazon, but Owala's Sway goes to Target and Ozark Trail goes to Walmart. Comments:
Part 3: Deep DivesAfter you've narrowed your search, check out the bottle's listing for more info. You can also look at this other post, which focuses less on rankings for each criteria and more on the individual features for each bottle.
Or if you've really narrowed it to just a few bottles, there are a couple links below.
Hope this helps, and happy hydrating!
Do Dents Affect Your Bottle's Insulation?Today we're exploring the question, will a dent affect your bottles insulation? Unless you have Spiderman-like reflexes, inevitably you will drop your bottle. Plastic bottles like Nalgenes will be fine, but dual-wall stainless steel bottles are a different story. Steel is a very strong and durable material for water bottle construction, but one major downside is that it is prone to denting. Many of these water bottles are not exactly cheap, costing as much as $50 for larger bottles from brands like YETI and Hydro Flask. So if you've invested in a brand you love, you want to know that your insulation still works, right? The truth is that dents CAN affect your bottle's insulation, but it's not as simple of a question to answer as it may seem at first. The location and size of the dent play a role, so there are more things to consdier than you might expect. So today we're exporing the question, "which dents affect your bottle's insulation?" Coming Next:
Video Review: Do Dents Affect Your Bottle's Insulation?I recently posted two videos about this test. One that's a 3-minute recap of the most important details, and another that's a full-length 18-minute video showing more of the testing footage and general information about these types of bottles. They each cover similar info as this post, so check those out if you'd prefer to watch the recap!
How Do Dual-Wall Insulated Bottles Work?Heat transfer through three primary methods:
Dual wall bottles work so well because they have a vacuum between the two stainless steel layers. Of the three heat transfer methods, only radiation is able to work through a vacuum. So when you have an intact vacuum, you're able to limit heat transfer in (or out) of your bottle. Another type of bottle you will see more and more commonly is what's normally referred to as a "triple-layer" bottle. These types of bottles have the same general construction as dual-wall bottles, but they add a copper coating to the outside of the inner stainless steel layer. The idea is that copper is better at limiting radiation heat transfer than steel, so this further improves the insulation properties of your bottle. To show you, I cut into a Hydro Flask (dual-wall) and a RevoMax (triple-layer with the copper coating). Fun fact, in the video you can actually hear the air rushing in to replace the vacuum when I cut through the Hydro Flask! Do Triple-Layer Bottles Work Better Than Dual-Wall Bottles?
Where Is The Worst Place On Your Bottle To Get A Dent?From cutting open these two bottles, I found that the spacing between the two layers is much wider on the bottom compared to the sides. So your bottle can have bigger dents on the bottom and still hold its insulation, which is probably by design because the bottom is the most likely place to get a dent. But if you are unlucky enough to drop your bottle on its side onto a rock or something else that dents it there, then the dent doesn't need to be as deep to create a contact point between the two layers. How Big Does A Dent Need To Be To Affect Your Bottle's Insulation?It's not just the location of the dent, but also the severity that matters. Insulation Failure A: Gradual Decrease Smaller isolated dents can create contact point between the two steel layers. Any contact point like this is going to be a pathway for heat transfer through conduction, so these dents can affect your insulation. But the good news is that your bottle will still have good insulation around the majority of it, so it won't be a complete failure. Insulation Failure B: Complete Loss (Vacuum No Longer Intact) Worst-case, you might get a larger dent that cuts through the outer layer of steel. This allows air to enter the space between the steel layers to replace the vaccum, and then your bottle will be not better at insulating than a single-wall bottle. Insulation TestsNext, I stress tested a RevoMax bottle by dropping it from increasing heights. I did a 4 hour insulation test before the test and after each drop. The bottle took A LOT of damage before the insulation was effected, even including some dents with extreme buckling and folding of the steel. The bottle still had the same insulation after 12", 24", 36", and 48" drops. Eventually the insulation was completely compromised (Failure B mentioned above) after the 60" drop. This occurred when multiple dents with severe buckling overlapped, and that overlapping area is where there was too much repeated strain on the steel to the point that it cut through the outer layer. So the main reason the insulation failed is because the compound dents overlapped. I wouldn't be surprised if the bottle would have held insulation after a single 60" drop. Conclusion: Do Dented Bottles Hold Insulation?In the vast majority of cases, YES! The bottom line is that you probably don't need to worry about your bottle's insulation being compromised by a dent. Most dents, even really severe ones, are not large enough to affect the insulation. Plus, the vast majority of people will replace their bottle before the insulation is affected because large dents can make the bottle sit wobbly, which is pretty annoying. But if you like to hang onto your bottles longer than the average person and you start to get overlapping major dents, that's when you would be more likely to start seeing your insulation get worse or potentially even competely fail. Do Your Own Insulation Test!But if you have any doubts, do an insulation test. Fill your bottle with the hottest water from your sink, measure the temperature, then let it sit for about 4 hours and measure it again. If the temperature dropped less than ~10 degrees F, your insulation is still probably good. More than ~10 degF and you might have a problem. How Do You Protect Your Bottle's Insulation?Other than never dropping your bottle EVER, there plenty of effective, easy options to keep your bottle protected and insulation as-designed. Here are a few to consider:
Good All-Around Sling for Many Bottles
Slings for 32 and 40oz Hydro Flasks
Bottle Boots
How Triple-Wall Bottles Work, and are They Worth the Hype? (Insulation Test vs Dual-Walls)8/24/2023 Do Triple-Wall Bottles Really Have Better Insulation than Dual-Wall Bottles?You’ve probably heard about dual-wall insulated bottles, but what about triple-wall? If two walls are good, then three are better, right? Let’s find out. Dual-wall stainless-steel bottles have been around for a long time, and brands like Hydro Flask and YETI really launched them into mainstream use within the last decade. Each bottle has two walls of stainless steel with a vacuum in between, and the lack of air reduces how much heat can transfer in or out. We tested quite a few of these bottles for a video earlier this year, and that turned into one of our best-performing posts. Triple wall bottles are not as widespread, but there are a few brands out there marketing this type of design, including S’well, RevoMax, EcoVessel, and Owala. We didn’t discuss this type of bottle as we would have liked in our previous insulation test video, so we thought now would be a good time to revisit it, this time with a focus on seeing if the triple-wall design is worth the marketing hype. Content Overview: Here's what we'll cover in case you'd like to skip ahead to a certain point.
Our Video Review
Our YouTube video covers the same information in this post, so click the link if you'd rather see the video. Otherwise, keep reading the full post below!
Before we get started, there are a few details to point out.
"Triple-Wall" vs "Triple-Layer"Many people assume triple-wall means three walls of stainless-steel, but that’s not correct. If you look closely at the marketing and listings, you’ll notice that it probably says “triple-layer” instead of “triple-wall.” It’s a small but significant distinction because they don’t really have three walls. They have the same dual wall construction with a vacuum in between, and the third layer refers to a copper coating on one of the stainless-steel walls. From S'well's website: “Thanks to our Therma-S'well® Technology and triple-layered insulation, which includes a copper layer, S'well products are able to keep any liquid hot or cold for long stretches, while maintaining a condensation-free exterior.” You might be wondering how this would help. Copper is known for being a good electrical conductor, but it also has a high thermal conductivity. This means that heat is transferred very easily through it, so why would a copper layer help bottle insulation? How Triple-Wall Bottles Limit Radiation Heat Transfer
The key difference with radiation compared to either conduction or convection is that radiation does not need matter to transfer heat, which allows for radiation heat loss through the vacuum in dual wall bottles. Emissivity: How Different Materials Allow Radiation Heat Transfer at Different RatesEmissivity is a material property that indicates how efficiently heat is transferred by radiation. A material with a lower emissivity value will transfer less radiant heat compared to a material with a higher value. Copper has an emissivity of 0.05, so while the copper coating won’t do much to prevent heat conduction, it will help prevent heat radiation. For reference, stainless-steel has a higher emissivity of 0.59, so the steel won’t prevent radiation heat loss as efficiently by itself. So that’s the science behind the triple-layer and how it theoretically is better, but how does this translate into actual results and is it significant enough of a difference for you to consider when buying a bottle? Let’s find out! Insulation Test A (Using a Uniform Styrofoam Cap)We looked at 14 total bottles. 11 bottles are dual-wall, and 3 have triple-layer insulation with the copper coating. Dual-Wall:
We were originally going to boil water to recreate steeping tea or brewing coffee, but it would have taken quite a few batches and taken a lot longer. So instead, we filled up each bottle with the hottest water from our sink. As mentioned before, different lids have different insulating properties. Because our main goal was to compare the triple-layer vs dual-wall insulation, we wanted to keep the different lid styles from impacting the results as much as possible. We purchased a sheet of Styrofoam insulation, cut it into a bunch of smaller pieces, and pressed them onto the rim of the bottles. This created an impression in the Styrofoam pieces that helped limit the potential for gaps and temperature loss. We poked a hole through each piece of foam with our thermometer, and we used a few other smaller pieces of insulation to cover up the holes when we weren’t taking measurements. Test A ResultsWe measured the temperature every hour for the next four hours, again around hour 8, and one more time around hour 20. With each measurement, we inserted the thermometer through the hole in the Styrofoam cap until the temperature equalized. This chart and graph show the percentage temperature change at different times during our test, which lasted 19 hours and 31 minutes. Temperature drops ranged between 17.2% on the low end to 27.0% on the high end. Looking closer at the data, there are a few interesting results to note. Two of the triple-layer bottles, RevoMax and S’well, had the best results. The third triple-layer bottle, EcoVessel, didn’t fare as well, but it was still in the top five. The best dual-wall bottle really surprised us. Ozark Trail, the Walmart brand bottle that we bought for $11, had an 18.5% temperature loss. Compare that to 20.9% for a $50 YETI Rambler and 24.2% for a $45 Hydro Flask. The worst bottle by a wide margin is Steepware, which is a bit ironic given that it’s primarily made for brewing tea. That being said, it’s probably not a major concern because most people will drink the tea within a few hours before it goes stale. So based on the results, it does appear that the copper layer may have an impact and helps insulation. However, depending on which brands you’re comparing, the difference between triple layer and dual wall insulation might not be as great as you would have thought. When you average the percent temperature loss for dual wall vs triple layer bottles, you get 22.7% and 18.3% respectively. A 5% difference over 20 hours is significant, but it’s not really game-changing in our opinion. However, there’s another big variable that makes this conclusion a bit uncertain. We can’t afford to buy every type of bottle, and it just so happens with our bottle collection that the two best performing bottles were also our only two narrow mouth bottles. Because most heat is lost through the lid and mouth opening, narrow mouth bottles should have an advantage over wide mouth ones. We’d like to do another test in the future that focuses on wide-mouth vs narrow-mouth insulation once we have more narrow mouth bottles to compare. Insulation Test B (Using the Manufacturer's Lid)But let’s face it, you’re not going to be walking around with one of these bottles with a Styrofoam cap. We did the test first because we wanted to isolate the effect that the copper layer has on the insulation, but the more practical test that you can use compares the bottles when using the lids that they come with. So we ran a 2nd version of the test using the bottle lids. For each measurement, we swapped the bottle lid with the Styrofoam piece from the previous test. Then we pushed the thermometer through the Styrofoam, and this prevented excessive temperature loss for the 15-20 seconds that we needed for each measurement. Once we had the reading, we put the normal cap back on. Test B ResultsThis test lasted for 19 hours and 17 minutes, and we made the same type of chart and table to show the results. Right away, there are some interesting data points and details to unpack. The relative rankings were mostly the same as with Test A, but there was a much wider range of results with a 13.5% temperature drop on the low end to 30.1% on the high end. That’s an increase in the range of results from 9.8% with Test A to 16.6% with Test B. The same two brands performed the best (RevoMax and S'well), but they widened their lead significantly. However, keep in mind that these are the only two narrow-mouth bottles in our test. Ozark Trail had a great showing again, and this was the best dual-wall bottle in both tests. Unfortunately for Steepware, this bottle was even more of an outlier on the wrong side of the average compared to Test A. Does the Bottle Manufacturer's Lid Help Insulation?While the relative rankings were similar for both tests, you may have noticed the rankings did change in some cases. For example, Hydro Flask’s Trail Series jumped from the 2nd worst with Test A to the middle of the pack with Test B. Since the only change between the two tests was that we switched from the standardized foam pieces to each brand’s lid, any changes in the rankings means that some brands have designed lids with better insulation than others. Standardizing the Results Tests A and B had slightly different total durations, so to better illustrate how the results for each bottle changed between the tests, we needed to standardize the results. We calculated the temperature drop per minute over the duration of both tests, then we multiplied that by 1200 to simulate a 20-hour test. Then we compared Test A vs Test B for each brand, and this graph shows how each brand changed. Bottles that fall on the left side had better results with their brand’s lids instead of the Styrofoam cap, and bottles on the right did better with the Styrofoam. S’well, RevoMax, and both Hydro Flasks were the only bottles that improved with Test B. When you look at the lids with each of these bottles, you can see that they seem to have more built-in insulation, like with S'well and RevoMax. Most of the other bottle lids like Steepware and Takeya don’t have built-in insulation and just have single layer plastic construction in the cap, so it’s understandable that they didn’t fare as well. Conclusions: Are Triple-Wall Bottles Worth the Hype?So when we take a step back and look at the results as a whole, we have a few main takeaways.
Based on these results, we have a few more video ideas that we may work on in the near future. Once we have more narrow-mouth bottles in our collection, we want to compare those against wide-mouth bottles. We also think it would be interesting to focus on premium brands vs budget brands, because let’s face it, we’re probably not the only ones that were surprised that Ozark Trail outperformed YETI. And finally, we only ran one instance of each test, and for more reliable comparisons and data, we ideally would repeat the test more times and average the results. Buying a Large Bottle? Keep Us in Mind!
Check out our Amazon store for fun and helpful accessories, like fruit infusers, cup holder adapters, and carrying slings.
|
Follow us for more hydration-focused updates!
Try searching for things like "infusers" or "Hydro Flask".
Categories
All
Archives
November 2025
Amazon Associates ProgramBottlePro is part of the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program. We strive to provide helpful information and product recommendations, and we receive a commission on purchases made after you click through our links.
|